- Joined
- Nov 26, 2006
- Messages
- 11,136
Modeling Contest #11 - Chimera
RESULTS
RESULTS
'Sup.
(SuPa-'s score / 2) + (Lord_T's score / 2) + (votes/(total votes))*50 = (score)
Skrab
SuPa- said:Mesh [13/15]
-The mesh is pretty decent, though a rather high polycount
Animation [8/10]
-Good use of in-game animations
-Includes many animations, as well
Texture [8/10]
-Includes team color
-Good use of in-game textures
Mechanics [5/5]
-Looks good in-game
-Functions properly
-Has a good portrait
Effects [4/5]
-It has a dissipate animation
-It has an attack sound
-Contains effects in the spell animation
-It has an attack sound
Creativity [3/5]
-It looks like it took some thought, but there are some pretty recognizable aspects to it
Total: 41
Lord_T said:Mesh- 13/15
Another nice mesh. Good blend of parts, and an overall likable mesh. The hydra heads are practically unaltered though.. D:
Animations- 10/10
Great! I don't see how any other in-game animation set could have worked here, and they're edited to look very nice with the additional parts.
Texture- 8/10
The use of ingames in nice, but I have a problem with the harsh transition from wolf to scale and from fur to wings,it could have been done better.
Mechanics- 4/5
Works perfectly, with 1 problem.
-1 Wolf death sound plays on attack.
Effects- 5/5
Nice splats and sounds. Looks fine.
Creativity- 5/5
Another interesting concept. Tastes a bit generic, but it's cool.
Final Score: 45
(41 / 2) + (45 / 2) + (22/48)*50 = 65.9166667
DonDustin
SuPa- said:Mesh [13/15]
-Another pretty good mesh
-There looks to be a bit of unnecessary geometry in the face
Animations [9/10]
-Another hefty set of well used in-game animations
Texture [7/10]
-There was an okay use of textures here, though a lot seemed distorted
-The moon necklace, or whatever it is, is in stark contrast to the rest
Mechanics [3/5]
-The portrait is decent
-The dear-like portion of the model seems to be pretty much a blob
Effects [5/5]
-It has blood effects
-It has a dissipate animation
-Includes a death sound
Creativity [2/5]
-There really is nothing much creative about this model in its general theme
Total: 39
Lord_T said:Mesh- 13/15
Quite a nifty mesh. The multiple layers of armor visible are neat, my only qualm is the helmet. Looks kinda ridiculous. Virtually seamless blend between torso and lower body.
-1 Kinda High poly
Animations- 9/10
Look incredible ingame, although they look silly and glichy in magos'. Most definately a good use of pitlord animations
-1 Death animation ends in a strange position, some of her is sticking through the ground.
Texture- 8/10
The Texture choice is very nice. It has some UV stretching issues, though.
Nice application of team color.
Mechanics- 5/5
Very nice appearance in-game, and the included icons are quite nice.
Effects- 4/5
Nice particles, an array of event sounds, but the blood effects are badly placed D:
Creativity- 3/5
An elf/stag... It's been done. However, the execution justifies it.
Final Score: 42
(39 / 2) + (42 / 2) + (10/48)*50 = 50.9166667
Xatoga
SuPa- said:Mesh [14/15]
-The mesh is pretty solid, with nothing really wrong with it
-Decent polycount
-UV Mapping seemed rather iffy
Animation [3/10]
-The animations are lacking, very static, and under exaggerated
-The attack animation appears to be looping
Texture [6/10]
-The texture is pretty blurry and undefined, especially on the model
-There is no team color, which could have been incorporated into, say, the eyes
Mechanics [3/5]
-The model itself looks decent enough in-game, despite its many flaws
Effects [1/5]
-As far as I could tell, it didn't have any effects
Creativity [5/5]
-Well, you did pretty good in this field, as I've really never seen something quite like this
Total: 32/50
Lord_T said:Mesh- 11/15
A nice mesh. Quite clean, and not too high-poly. Very original.
-1 Seam of the model gives odd shading ingame... Looks like it wasn't welded.
Animations- 4/10
Despite how silly they look in magos, when applied to a gryphon rider, the model looks acceptable.
-2: Looping attack and death animations.
Texture- 7/10
The texture looks nice in-game, and it goes well with the model.
-1 The skin is a bit undefined, and stretches in some places.
-1 No Team color
Mechanics- 2/5
-3 Walk anim is stiff, and death and attack animations loop.
Effects- 0/5
No particles or events....
Creativity- 5/5
Very nice concept, I like it alot... A quadropedal spidercrow.
Final Score: 29
(32 / 2) + (29 / 2) + (16/48)*50 = 47.1666667
| 1st - Skrab 2nd - DonDustin 3rd - Xatoga |
Also, apparently Lord_T can't count. 
