Keeper of Souls v1.1b

[Moderator]

Orcnet

07:56, 20th Aug 2013

Comment

Review

Map Approved

Keepers of Souls (Version 1.1b) Rate Score Percent Letter 5/5 91-100 A Rate Score Percent Letter 4/5 81-90% B Rate Score Percent Letter 3/5 75-80% C Rate Score Percent Letter 2/5 70-74% D Rate Score Percent Letter 1/5 50-69% F Overview: Gameplay "Gameplay is neat well executed, though it would be fair rated and all but still its cool." Terrain "Terrain is awesome, that unique way of lava SFX gave the map more realism than using the game's default lava texture, good choice." Management "In short, map is recommended." Total Score: Rate Score Percent Letter 10/15 83% B

 

[UndeadImmortal]

The map was fun when I played it while on the mini-mapping contest, tho the effects maybe laggy to some users that have low pc statistics.

 

[deathismyfriend]

“Review Inside“

REVIEW

The ratings are weighted depending on what type of map it is. What I mean by weighted is that I give a possible of 45/45 but if they only add up to 22/45 it doesn’t mean that your final rating is a 2/5 I weigh the fields differently. For instance Gameplay is a lot more important than spells.

TRIGGERS	Don’t use dying unit / casting unit / entering unit use triggering unit. The only time you need and conditions is inside an or conditions block. Anything with center of / position of / offset / random point leaks. Anything used twice or more should be stored into a variable and the variable should be used. Your leaks definitely need to be fixed or they will start to lag on some computers. 1/5
SPELLS	The spells will eventually cause lag. They are unique. 2/5
TOOLTIPS	The tooltips look good. Haven’t seen anything wrong yet. 5/5
TERRAIN	The terrain is different and interesting and fits the story well. 5/5
GAME MESSAGES	The game messages are good in the beginning. They are informative. You tell us what we have to kill but you should also ping one of the souls to kill in the beginning as it is a little unclear on what they are. 4/5
CINEMATICS	The opening cinematic is interesting. It is a little short though. It would be better if you showed a little more. 1/5
ARTWORK	The artwork is interesting and fits great with the story. 5/5
GAMEPLAY	The Gameplay is fun. It can use some small improvements. Maybe lower the amount of souls to kill in the beginning and increase there health or speed. To make it harder to kill them. 3/5
FINAL RATING	It can use some improvements on balancing. You should ping locations when telling someone to do something. You should give the players a little more time to capture souls and get started in the game. 3/5

[/TD][/tr]
If you have any questions or problems with my review please tell me.
"Table Review template by Doomlord".

 

[DSanhueza]

“Review Inside“

REVIEW

The ratings are weighted depending on what type of map it is. What I mean by weighted is that I give a possible of 45/45 but if they only add up to 22/45 it doesn’t mean that your final rating is a 2/5 I weigh the fields differently. For instance Gameplay is a lot more important than spells.

TRIGGERS	Don’t use dying unit / casting unit / entering unit use triggering unit. The only time you need and conditions is inside an or conditions block. Anything with center of / position of / offset / random point leaks. Anything used twice or more should be stored into a variable and the variable should be used. Your leaks definitely need to be fixed or they will start to lag on some computers. 1/5
SPELLS	The spells will eventually cause lag. They are unique. 2/5
TOOLTIPS	The tooltips look good. Haven’t seen anything wrong yet. 5/5
TERRAIN	The terrain is different and interesting and fits the story well. 5/5
GAME MESSAGES	The game messages are good in the beginning. They are informative. You tell us what we have to kill but you should also ping one of the souls to kill in the beginning as it is a little unclear on what they are. 4/5
CINEMATICS	The opening cinematic is interesting. It is a little short though. It would be better if you showed a little more. 1/5
ARTWORK	The artwork is interesting and fits great with the story. 5/5
GAMEPLAY	The Gameplay is fun. It can use some small improvements. Maybe lower the amount of souls to kill in the beginning and increase there health or speed. To make it harder to kill them. 3/5
FINAL RATING	It can use some improvements on balancing. You should ping locations when telling someone to do something. You should give the players a little more time to capture souls and get started in the game. 3/5

[/TD][/tr]
If you have any questions or problems with my review please tell me.
"Table Review template by Doomlord".

I fixed most of the stuff you mentioned, removed unnecessary special effects and I'd say I removed all leaks, I also revamped some zones and fixed other stuff.

Thanks for the review man!

 

[Orcnet]

Map approved, see moderator comment on top.

 

[Legal_Ease]

Congratulations on making this months top 3!

 

[deepstrasz]

-when imps die, the die forever?

3/5.