Imadori said:
* Can't we make the posts shorter? Maximum of one paragraph, maybe.
Not everyone has the time nor passion to read & write long stories and posts.
I think that post length is for the roleplayers to decide. Minimal and Maximal sizes for a post is unnecessary rules, since as the RP's seriousness forms from time to time, longer and shorter posts might be needed. There is a main pattern that everyone follows at the moment, and that pattern can change over time. If someone is creating a post that doesn't fit, as a community we can tell them to change it. For example trolman's first post in the RP, which followed the DP style.
* Reading and understanding the lore itself plus the character's (side or main chars), feels like studying, especially when you're already excited to write your first post... Studying is the last thing on my mind right now. How about making sure everyone can join the RP easily without having to read much of those?
This i find very true. I want to create the world that is easy to join in, but always holds something more to explore. "Easy to play, hard to master" style. How i want to manage this? I want to create TLDR QuickStarter packs for newcomers. Some vital info on the world and it's current state, in images and short paragraphs. The history will inevitably be longer over time, but I want to create a more loose link between world history, and current month's theme.
* Can't we just remove the 'Beginning/Backstory' thing? Every one except the veterans here just wants to put their focus on their characters alone.
I doubt the new comers will read others' background unless you make it mandatory, which, I think, will kill the idea of 'future active members'. It's the same as being forced to read the lore.
This can be solved by having the characters develop through time instead of writing backstories. Maybe fragments of memories will work too? Short flashbacks I mean.
As i see backstories were never a thing in Kaelicious. It all started with small posts, and our characters evolved with the RP itself. I wont make Backstories mandatory in the future, however every character should have attributes that differentiates them from others. If someone would like to write down his/her backstory, I wont forbid that either.
* Quit adding characters! We can't follow!
It might be fun having to control and interact with new toys, but the readers (possible future members) don't appreciate this. The problem is, this is not a book. Readers will only read latest posts. They won't bother with our char's history and such. They just wanted to read something interesting right here and now. It'll be troublesome for them to understand what's going on if they don't know who's who.
I understand that following the current state is hard. As Bernkastel wrote, a Character Introduction thread will be made, and should be updated from month to month, always with the current info.
If someone wants to join a storyline, he will have to read those short introductions anyways.
Not everyone is interested in roleplaying to begin with. I think we must cater to them if we want this RP to stay active, plus get more members.
Thats true. If you dont know what is RP-ing, its almost impossible to join on your own. But I want members that join despite they cant RP. To join the contest, join the Kaelicious community. I want to make contests more frequently, and RPing will not be mandatory, but will reward the contestants. That's how I imagine to get members.
Well, those are just opinions, I don't mean to be offensive.
Wow, you were not offensive at all! I really appreciate that you shared your opinions, which are quite right. If you have further ideas, i would be happy to hear it. It is hard to satisfy old members and new members at the same time. Hence it is important to hear your ideas and desires, so we can create a better world together.
