Four

[Moderator]

12:59, 3rd Feb 2009
Septimus: Approve.

12:14, 24th June 2009
Rui: Rejected.

 

[Fisher621]

Heres my Review:
+ Acceptable Terrain and Quality
---------------------------------
/Annoying Huge Aura ( But its Acceptable but i think its annoying, )

/Lack of Critters ( only critters are waterborne sheep in the water and i dont see any harbor or such so you can have ships, pretty useless.

/ Lack of Description

My Rating: 1/5

 

[yakonshus]

/Annoying Huge Aura ( But its Acceptable but i think its annoying, )

/Lack of Critters ( only critters are waterborne sheep in the water and i dont see any harbor or such so you can have ships, pretty useless.

The huge map size is made small with the boundaries, so the more is less.

I dont find it lacking critters, as critters like stags and pigs would spoil the atmosphere, and the meaning of the map is not to use the water, and by the way, critters are always useless (pretty fun to slaughter though)

But thanks for the reply anyway

 

[Septimus]

The boundary should have never been set up and the terrain still been improve.

The description at hiveworkshop need to be improve and the marketplace was partically pointless.

Creep amount was overkill, 9 creep guarding 1 gold mine (Gold mine with player starting location) while the other gold mine are left undefend ? @[email protected]

Apart from Tavern, every neutral structure should be guarded except gold mine with player starting location (Refer to 1 vs 1 map).

Quality seems to be acceptable.

2/5 from me.