19:36, 3rd Aug 2010
ap0calypse: Approved

 

when i played this game, it was ununderstandable, you have 5 sec to read everything before each waves, well i remember versions 3 or 4 years ago and it was better

 

Thanks for your feedback. Can you tell me more specifically where and what is it more harder to understand so i can improve on it?

 

This sounds thoroughly interesting. At first I thought this was a different version of DotA and I almost skipped it. I have to ask though, besides the conquest mode what do you do before that??

 

Before the Conquest Mode, its a hero defense where you have to defend the fountain from 15 waves of spell packed creeps, 5 waves of general creeps and 3 bosses + Sargeras.

 

nice map!

 

wow, christmas edition. ^_^

 

we've less 30s for choose a hero at the begining, and it's too short !!! that's bad when players are afk...
one other thing, it's normal (in solo) when i pass the first event, i lost the control of my hero ? i understand (during the event), but when the game continue, i can't control my hero anymore...

can you fix it plz? i like your map it's funny

 

There is 1 minute choosing time before creep starts rushing in. The Totems can be attacked and will take the bulk of the damage on that lane if the player afk at the beginning.

Losing control of your hero means the hero disappear, cannot move or change player control?

Oh and thanks for playing my map, glad you enjoyed it

 

screenshots would be nice..

 

Screenshots is on facebook. Its at the top of the page.



*NEW* Click Like and discuss/view screenshots for Defense of the Titans on Facebook!

http://www.facebook.com/pages/Defense-of-the-Titans/160554590663969?v=photos

 

I may try again later but first try was bad experience.

Suggestions

Defense of the Titans
====
Systems
---
The first minigame was broken; the Void Beasts just stood there.
====
Gameplay
---
how are we supposed to live with two players?! You should really implement a system to compensate for the number of players, or individual players can't realistically play your map.
--
The opening "teach me how to play this" cutscene went WAY too fast. If you could make it a bit more concise and slow it down, you'd not only avoid confusing (and scaring off) new players, but also avoid taking up too much time.
====
Graphics
---
Overall, your map was pretty well made from a standpoint of looks. For a map that is designed to have functional terrain over beautiful, I can't complain on this.
====
Misc
---
Did you intend "Pantheon" instead of "Patheon?"
--
A random "ur" snuck in with otherwise formal and accurate language in the tutorial cinematic.

 

Hello~ Thanks for ur feedback!
I'll answer some questions below.

My reply to XPQJ's feedback here.

Defense of the Titans
====
Systems
---
The first minigame was broken; the Void Beasts just stood there.

Umm, the void beasts were just decorations. You are supposed to stun/compete with each other to reach the waygate first. Perhaps that will change in future versions where they will move and attack players.
====
Gameplay
---
how are we supposed to live with two players?! You should really implement a system to compensate for the number of players, or individual players can't realistically play your map.


Okay, I shall elaborate. The spawn rate increases with the number of players and that in turn increases the difficulty of defending the fountain from the leaking waves. One leaking wave in 8 players at level 10 and above could mean game lost in 5 seconds while 10 seconds in 2 players.

There are also incentives to lesser people. With lesser people, the limited edition loots, gold and other drops from bosses are shared between fewer players and that makes you much more stronger than playing in a 5-8 players game.

The only reasons for losing in my opinion are,
* All heroes died, leaving the fountain vulnerable to attacks.
If this is the reason, did you buy bonus health items and stronger potions? If you did there shouldn't be any problem in defeating bosses in normal mode.

* One side leaked at late game waves.
2 Players means there are 2 towers and 2 heroes. The towers should be able to hold their stand if you upgrade them simultaneously. You can also buy the Tower Building skill to increase ur defense.

Personally i have tested DotT with my friend everyday with 1 or 2 of my friends and the only part where it's challenging is at Sargeras. Perhaps you did not equip yourselves with enough vitality items or you did not purchase strong potions to heal fast enough. As i said above, DotT is not an Easy game and need to play a few games to learn the ropes.
--
The opening "teach me how to play this" cutscene went WAY too fast. If you could make it a bit more concise and slow it down, you'd not only avoid confusing (and scaring off) new players, but also avoid taking up too much time.

Okay I will summarise more and slow it down.
====
Graphics
---
Overall, your map was pretty well made from a standpoint of looks. For a map that is designed to have functional terrain over beautiful, I can't complain on this.

There was alot of doodads that have to be deleted due to lag issues. The game had sacrificed doodads to reduce lag.
====
Misc
---
Did you intend "Pantheon" instead of "Patheon?"

It's Patheon. May i know where did the text error occur?
--
A random "ur" snuck in with otherwise formal and accurate language in the tutorial cinematic.

Thanks for pointing that out, I will fix it in the next version.

-----------------------------------
Again thanks for taking the time to feedback to me about the game! I really appreciate it and I hope to hear more from you in the future. ^^

Oh, you can check out DotT guides below, I think it will help you handle the game with just 2 players easily after reading the guides.
http://www.facebook.com/pages/Defense-of-the-Titans/160554590663969?v=app_2373072738

 

Epic epic epic epic!!!!!
EDIT:
just played it here's my review
heroes:5/5 *storylines are pretty good, have only played sword saint*
difficulty:4/5 *game is BRUTAL IN SINGLEPLAYER*
terrain:4/5 *i like snow but that's too icy*
minigames:5/5 *whos doesn't like mini games*

rating 10!

 

Item descriptions too long, the scoreboard blocked some item names, try improving on item descriptions and the recipe part was rather messy also. For some reason, I can't wield the Awakened Rune Rapier as well.

 

My reply to Torankasu feedback.

Item descriptions too long, the scoreboard blocked some item names,
Scoreboard can be hidden by typing -hl. Press f9 and check out the available commands.

try improving on item descriptions and the recipe part was rather messy also.
Recipe messy and item descriptions not clear? Not sure about that cause every prerequisite item required to form the Recipe Item have clear instructions on how to obtain them in the description and you can buy the item directly if you wan to skip crafting.

For some reason, I can't wield the Awakened Rune Rapier as well.
Yes this had been noted. Christmas II is undergoing Beta Test as of this post and will be released soon which fixes many stuffs including this.

Thanks for your feedback, very much appreciated.
Dragoncy

 

yes.... Dragoncy is back with the now more uber map! xD GJ.

cant wait for the newer version!

 

I think its very fun, but could use some polishing/ more heroes. One bug I found was the Ancient Rune Rapier recipe would combine even if you had one already in your inventory (I had an awakened one) and destroy it but not reset the kill count. I had an unawakened rune rapier with the kills going over 400 before I ragequit. It seems like ascendance activates far less than it should (that might just be me). And the ninja with the lightning jump can cross the map (leave challenges etc.). If a new wave spawns when you are in challenge they do not freeze and can destroy or attack your fountain (this almost happened before I upgraded my tower to take care of them). Fatal error happens if you are afk at start and death race minigame happens before hero choose.

 

Sry for the late reply!

My reply to Naman feedback.