BTNPhoenix

[Moderator]

13:50, 14th Aug 2009
zombie2279: Terrible. No definition, shading, highlights, a proper detailed object and it's almost entirely irrelevant to the icon's title. It's also messy and pixelated, and the DISATC is all wrong.

Rejected.

 

[mnib]

estimate

 

[TheHunterKiller]

Looks a bit blurry, also what's wrong with the DISATC?

 

[mnib]

dunno why it turned to be gray colour when i used function it was black
still best to us btn and atc passive looks kinda crappy

 

[Somnium]

Hey dude, sorry for disturbing you but I must request WIPs. This icon is pixeletad, which is an often charasteristic of C'n'P so please provide WIP or layered .psd file.

 

[mnib]

and how should i find those wips or smth?
i dont know about all those files was making icon with tutorial and picture was made in gimp

 

[mnib]

u wanted this?

 

[X-OMG-X]

hmm fix the disattc and sharpen the icon a bit and i think it would be good
4/5 if you fix it

 

[mnib]

i will upg it if they accept it on hive cause if they say i jsut took some photo than theres no sense

 

[Panda]

Theirs no need for him too show WIPS for this particular icon. Anyways the DISATC is all wrong, and you need to show more of the phoenix in your picture.

 

[LsK_LaDyGaGa]

I like it. Could be used as a reincarnation as well.

 

[mnib]

yes its more for reincarnate it kinda shows like phonix just went out of egg and started burning eveything around

 

[Licheus]

It could be good if it wasn't that pixilated. To be approved you certainly need to make it much clearer.