Battalion Siege 1.29

[Moderator]

06:59, 5th Jul 2011
-Kobas-:
Status: Rejected

 

[light bolt30]

Improve the description; tell us more about gameplay, anything special, heroes, items, screenshots, etc. Here's a list of BB Codes for you.

 

[siLveRniGhtz]

Thanks for your suggestions lightbolt30, Malaysia internet is bullsh*t, i will have a hard time uploading screenshots. So here is the full descriptions : http://forum.ucpro.my/thread-92803-1-1.html

 

[light bolt30]

It's nice to have a description on another site as well as here otherwise the current description is lacking and can lead the map to rejection even if it was a really good quality map.

 

[siLveRniGhtz]

Cant seem to upload screenshots...

 

[light bolt30]

Upload the images to an image hosting site e.g imgshack,etc or upload it into the Hive's album then get it's link and post it between the

codes which can be found inside the list of BB Codes.

 

[siLveRniGhtz]

Okay, i will do that when im free. thank you.

 

[HolyFireX]

Lol siLveRniGhtz where do you live?? (I am also in malaysia...)

 

[siLveRniGhtz]

Johor Bahru =.=

 

[JGGDMakervb6]

Improve description
U will need to update the description right now cuz some peoples only look at the 1st page of maps.
The map will be moved to 2nd page when new maps are made so improve it

 

[ZlolZ]

LoL... This map totally sucks.. bored... HAHAHA JOKING MY BRO!!! It's Totally special - mixture of DotA, Castle Fight and Warcraft (RTS), its kinda fun though! For me, I'll rate it 4/5! Good work!

 

[sPy]

Hello there~ I'm Malaysian too, anyway, here's my revivew:

Still brings some fun, until the next 25 minutes... I started to get bored with it because of slow lumber harvesting.

The heroes are not really the main role in this game, so I'm not going to talk about it.

Upgrades has proper descriptions, so it's good enough. However, the units has some problems. Telling how good a unit isn't going to help the player understand. This might be hard, but doing it might greatly increase your gameplay fun-factor, such as below:
- Give the information of the unit's health, attack damage, armor etc.

Here's some thing that looked weird to me:

I already give you details about the picture 2, 3 and 4.
For the picture 1, to do that, download this:
Sorry about the MPQ extractor, I actually meant this.
Download the Button Manager here.

NOTE: This review meant nothing, just what I thought and no offense is intended.

 

[siLveRniGhtz]

Hello there~ I'm Malaysian too, anyway, here's my revivew:

Still brings some fun, until the next 25 minutes... I started to get bored with it because of slow lumber harvesting.

The heroes are not really the main role in this game, so I'm not going to talk about it.

Upgrades has proper descriptions, so it's good enough. However, the units has some problems. Telling how good a unit isn't going to help the player understand. This might be hard, but doing it might greatly increase your gameplay fun-factor, such as below:
- Give the information of the unit's health, attack damage, armor etc.

Here's some thing that looked weird to me:
View attachment 94605 View attachment 94606 View attachment 94607 View attachment 94608
I already give you details about the picture 2, 3 and 4.
For the picture 1, to do that, download this:
Sorry about the MPQ extractor, I actually meant this.
Download the Button Manager here.

NOTE: This review meant nothing, just what I thought and no offense is intended.

Thanks for your reviews and i will try to fix all of it, but have u tried the better lumber harvesters? Since u said the lumber was slow.

Are u spylordz147?

 

[Wanza]

Hello, siLveRniGhtz, you ask that you need a terrain polisher, don't you ?
which side do you need to be polished ? well, i'll help you little bit if you want..
well, so many Malaysian here,, I'm Indonesian

 

[Eldubs]

I dont usually like futuristick maps, but this one got my attention. Il try it out someday, and if if it deserves il give it a review.

 

[x3GlikE]

Testing give you review soon

 

[siLveRniGhtz]

Hope everyone enjoy my map =)

 

[siLveRniGhtz]

Bump?

 

[shadire]

Cons:Spirit eaters die in half a second, super weapons aren't to strong, bad description on Hive

Notes: At the top it says gold is not used in the game but you mine it and earn it, at the portal by Firescar it says "(edited)" I doubt you want that there,

Pros: Variety of units, interesting evolution of lumberjacks, good gameplay, Variety of buildings

Overall Rating: 3.5

Suggestions: Try and add A.I. if it's possible, make a better description detailing gameplay, heroes, et cetra

 

[siLveRniGhtz]

Thanks for the feedback dude. will take your suggestions.

 

[-BLOOD_BATH-]

Seems interesting, will test it soon.
I'm going to gather money first.
=====
EDIT
=====
Oh yeah, interesting one.
Gampelay: Nice and fun, provoke players to quickly to click-that-click-it, make players not bored. But, I just want to critic the skills. Players will have hard time to target enemies or area (using skills), why not make it auto-cast? But, well, 3/5
Terrain: Well, I think it's good. But, about the need of terrain polisher, it's depend on you. 3/5
Description: Oh yes... very nice, but, that's not very important
Bugs: So far I've not seen any bugs. But, I don't know it's just me or not, every time Ranger (hero) is trained, there is an about 5 sec lag. I don't know this is a bug or not. Anyway, that's not so important. 5/5
Suggestions:
-The auto-cast thingies
-How about... something creative like land mines? And walls(or maybe it's already exists, don't know)?
-Domination mode?
-More heroes? Each heroes are divided with different categories, or something like that
Good luck in your project!

 

[siLveRniGhtz]

Seems interesting, will test it soon.
I'm going to gather money first.
=====
EDIT
=====
Oh yeah, interesting one.
Gampelay: Nice and fun, provoke players to quickly to click-that-click-it, make players not bored. But, I just want to critic the skills. Players will have hard time to target enemies or area (using skills), why not make it auto-cast? But, well, 3/5
Terrain: Well, I think it's good. But, about the need of terrain polisher, it's depend on you. 3/5
Description: Oh yes... very nice, but, that's not very important
Bugs: So far I've not seen any bugs. But, I don't know it's just me or not, every time Ranger (hero) is trained, there is an about 5 sec lag. I don't know this is a bug or not. Anyway, that's not so important. 5/5
Suggestions:
-The auto-cast thingies
-How about... something creative like land mines? And walls(or maybe it's already exists, don't know)?
-Domination mode?
-More heroes? Each heroes are divided with different categories, or something like that
Good luck in your project!

Thanks for viewing, but what do you mean on the Domination mode?

 

[-BLOOD_BATH-]

Oh I mean when team 1 successfully conquer the middle lane, then team 1 get bonus income.
*Generally, maker of the maps place one circle in the middle of the lane, and if team 1 walk on the circle, then they got bonus...(depending on your mind)
Or you can add other variation about that mode, ex if team 2 successfully conquer the middle lane that has been conquered by team 1 previously, team 1 got minus gold/depending on your mind.
Good luck in your project!

 

[siLveRniGhtz]

Oh I mean when team 1 successfully conquer the middle lane, then team 1 get bonus income.
*Generally, maker of the maps place one circle in the middle of the lane, and if team 1 walk on the circle, then they got bonus...(depending on your mind)
Or you can add other variation about that mode, ex if team 2 successfully conquer the middle lane that has been conquered by team 1 previously, team 1 got minus gold/depending on your mind.
Good luck in your project!

Nice suggestion seriously. will try to implement it. Tq^^