Autumnwoods

[Moderator]

19:01, 15th Mar 2014
Orcnet:

This is such a promissing melee map. And having a low file size is a plus. Judging from the mini-map I could already tell that this is a balanced map. IDK for other things so downloading... for the review.

The Hive Workshop Official

Map Reviewer: eubz Map Name: Autumnwoods Map Author: Super Jakiro Map Uploader: Super Jakiro Originality As an overall impression, This map is just another Altered Melee map with few things being changed. What should be done is to add a new race. This map just used default races I guess. Score: 28/100 Critical Error -> Vote for Rejection! Presentation You have your map informations presented. The features and change logs are also presented including all the necessary persons to give credits to. One thing is that you just need to polish it using some bb codes. Score: 10/100 Critical Error -> Vote for Rejection! Design Map design is cool. As I said, it is very much symmetrical and has a potential. Score: 49/100 Terrain I like the terrain, it is too balanced but the trees and the land textures are contrasting. The doodads are well placed and neutral units, too. Score: 58/100 Triggers I have nothing to say about the triggers because it uses the Default melee game initialization for all players. Score: 51/100 Object Data I am not much pleased because many of the units and heroes used the default models while you just change some properties of others. Good that you have imported stuff, though. Score: 41/100 Gameplay During the game, since this is an altered melee map, I am thinking that a new race will emerge but sadly, no new race has come out. Instead, each race has a unit replacements just like footmen replaced by soldiers and some other changes on basic races has been done, too. During the game, since this is an altered melee map, I am thinking that a new race will emerge but sadly, no new race has come out. Instead, each race has a unit replacements just like footmen replaced by soldiers and some other changes on basic races has been done, too. Score: 13/100 Critical Error -> Vote for Rejection! MORE SUGGESTIONS: 1. If you can create a new race that'll be better. 2. You can either change the type of trees to use or change the land textures to fit with the trees. 3. Fix your description. Map still in development? Make a thread in the Map Development Section for feedback. Need help with triggers/memory leaks? Make a thread in the Triggers & Scripts Section. Tutorials Final Score: 35.714/100 1/5 Vote for Rejection Contact: (Visitor Message) / (Private Message) / (Map Reviewers)

 

[Vinz]

It looks like a cool map, looking at the features. I'll review the map soon upon finishing a game with it. If I don't do it within a few days, just spam my PM box(which is almost always full, so you'll have to resort to VMs).

 

[Heinvers]

Looks good. Can u provide at least a screenshot?

 

[Vinz]

Tree of Eternity can entangle goldmine global

Did you just make the Night Elves OP?

 

[SuperJakiro]

Did you just make the Night Elves OP?

Not just making them OP.. it just it's another strategy on how a player use the Global entangle .. but requires to build ToL just in case the main base with under attack .. and also if playing with AIs will help NE players to get expansions ..

 

[SuperJakiro]

Looks good. Can u provide at least a screenshot?

I can't still get on how to put a screenshot but still I'm updating Map I'm gonna send the screenshot once I learn to use the codes on the Hive ..

 

[Heinvers]

I know it's an altered melee. I just want to see how the terrain looks. Don't worry.

23) Warden learn Critical Strike

And I sense that the Warden will be my favorite hero

 

[SuperJakiro]

I know it's an altered melee. I just want to see how the terrain looks. Don't worry.
And I sense that the Warden will be my favorite hero

yeah i just replace shadow stike ability w/ critical strike .. ok I'm gonna get some screenshot ..

 

[Vinz]

No. :c
Maybe replace Blink with a Backstab or so. It's the most hated OP skill.

 

[eubz]

This is such a promissing melee map. And having a low file size is a plus. Judging from the mini-map I could already tell that this is a balanced map. IDK for other things so downloading... for the review.

The Hive Workshop Official

Map Reviewer: eubz Map Name: Autumnwoods Map Author: Super Jakiro Map Uploader: Super Jakiro Originality As an overall impression, This map is just another Altered Melee map with few things being changed. What should be done is to add a new race. This map just used default races I guess. Score: 28/100 Critical Error -> Vote for Rejection! Presentation You have your map informations presented. The features and change logs are also presented including all the necessary persons to give credits to. One thing is that you just need to polish it using some bb codes. Score: 10/100 Critical Error -> Vote for Rejection! Design Map design is cool. As I said, it is very much symmetrical and has a potential. Score: 49/100 Terrain I like the terrain, it is too balanced but the trees and the land textures are contrasting. The doodads are well placed and neutral units, too. Score: 58/100 Triggers I have nothing to say about the triggers because it uses the Default melee game initialization for all players. Score: 51/100 Object Data I am not much pleased because many of the units and heroes used the default models while you just change some properties of others. Good that you have imported stuff, though. Score: 41/100 Gameplay During the game, since this is an altered melee map, I am thinking that a new race will emerge but sadly, no new race has come out. Instead, each race has a unit replacements just like footmen replaced by soldiers and some other changes on basic races has been done, too. During the game, since this is an altered melee map, I am thinking that a new race will emerge but sadly, no new race has come out. Instead, each race has a unit replacements just like footmen replaced by soldiers and some other changes on basic races has been done, too. Score: 13/100 Critical Error -> Vote for Rejection! MORE SUGGESTIONS: 1. If you can create a new race that'll be better. 2. You can either change the type of trees to use or change the land textures to fit with the trees. 3. Fix your description. Map still in development? Make a thread in the Map Development Section for feedback. Need help with triggers/memory leaks? Make a thread in the Triggers & Scripts Section. Tutorials Final Score: 35.714/100 1/5 Vote for Rejection Contact: (Visitor Message) / (Private Message) / (Map Reviewers)

 

[Orcnet]

The map is given quite a interesting changes but somehow its too little for it to be accepted.

Would be better if you can expansively redo all the races and how the alteration of the tech tree would be rare, more likely new items, spells including new modes on what the melee genre couldn't provide.

For now it needs such changes and the review above has explained some.

 

[SuperJakiro]

Thank You for all the feed backs .. Now I know what to do .. but still .. I'm thinking about new races .. and it's to complicated to finish as soon as possible because I need to continue my College Study .. but I'll always updating my Maps when it's my free time .. I'm gonna upload the Final Product when I finished it .. This is Just my preview of my map .. But still Thank You for the Feed backs.. I appreciate it .. and give me some more Ideas of what would I gonna do ..

Once Again Thank Youuuuuuuuuuu !