Moderator
M
Moderator
2010, ap0: Rejected
12:03, 18th Dec 2009
ap0calypse: Rejected
12:03, 18th Dec 2009
ap0calypse: Rejected
(4 ratings)
Review
[+] Terrain: Non Blizzard Cliff tiles. Imported doodads used ok.
[+] Professions: Its good to see that you added Professions
[+] RPG: RPG's are usually good games and i say this is a good game
[-] Not Finished: Its not finished but when you finish it you will get a higher rating
[-] Creeps: The starting creeps are too strong, get some ideas from WoW
Review: Astral, its good to see that your map doesnt use Cliff tiles because they are ugly and very fustrating to work with in making a map.
You also have imported doodads means that you know what you are doing, trust i've seen maps that are cliff and no doodads...
Professions are a great resource in the game, it adds more then just killing creeps and doing quest.
RPG's can be the funest games, 'can' doesnt mean all the time, but it looks like this one is going to succeed.
Its really a shame this map isnt finished, but when it is... Its going to be good, theres one big bug bear... The starting creeps are too strong, i kept dying...
3/5 > +rep
Thanks mate, thanks a lot, you are first one who gave me 5/5 xD Now i need some time to get more ideas but update will be in 2 or 3 days.Today is my birthday so ill take this compliment as gift xD (best one)
Review:
Story:-, i don't even know if there is a story, so i'll just leave this blank.My Ratings value
5/5 for Perfect
4/5 for Really Good
3/5 for Good
2/5 for Fair
1/5 for Bad
0/5 for Horrible
For Overall Rating:
15 - 20 for Perfect/Excellent
10 - 15 for Really Good/Fair
05 - 10 for Bad/No fun
00 - 05 for Horrible/Disgusting
Quests:2/5, well first of all, the quest dialogues are very, very bad. I was walking around and suddenly someone says "Kill 3 young wolves! I will give you a nice reward.", a better quest receive system could have been used, for example a cinematic or at least 2 buttons, saying "Accept" or "deny". This is just not acceptable.
Combat:-, combat will not be rated.
Sounds/effects/skills/Models/Skins:2/5, There aren't a lot of custom models, but it's a single player rpg, so i guess there could have been more. And the storm strike ability or whatever it's called, doesn't even have an effect, nothing. The game is very "empty", you just suddenly get a quest from someone, who tells you to kill X wolves for example. And if i'm not wrong, there aren't any systems in the game, which every rpg usually has, at least 1 or 2. For example an attack system or custom hero selection, so you can choose between classes and not just get a shaman. I could go on listing other issues, but what i would suggest is learning advanced gui or jass(there are a lot of tutorials, which are very helpful), so that you can make a small system or a small cinematic. I would highly suggest, you play some of the other rpgs that are uploaded in the hive, to get some ideas etc.
Terrain:3/5, the terrain was well made, but there are some areas that could use some improvements.
Gameplay/Fun factor2/5, well there is no cinematic in the beginning or anything, there's just an orc shaman hero in the middle of a forest, without any info on the map or story.
Bugs/Hive Description factorN/A, the hive description is acceptable. But you should use some colors and make the titles bold.
Overall:9/20, well i don't have anything else to say, just read all the 4 most important things i mentioned above and you will be able to improve your rpg.
09/20: Bad
Comment: "...Unappealing..."
When you step on all switches, dry rock will appear on ruined temple.Its on a hill under big mountain where you found guardian companion.Actualy i havent made special item called dry rock i just used one blizzard campain item, without changing its text but it shouldnt be hard to find out what it is when quest tells you where you should expect one, i will update map once i fix all bugs, and expand map.
I wouldnt call that laziness, i just forget to change item's description and name but ill do it.Yeah, I did that... I got some kind of Gemstone instead, which would probably be the standard blizzard quest item you're talking about.
Laziness taking over?
I can try to once I get home, I'm currently at school... ><I ask again, if there is anyone who can unprotect map for me now i am much advanced mapper then time i was making this, now i could fix story line and make more better quests and also fix old ones.And i think some bosses like infernal and air elemental are very strong they might need weakening.
I can try to once I get home, I'm currently at school... ><
It isn't.wow now this map is rejected what do you will?