''An Interview with Muhammed''

[TheDivineBoss]

Yes, yes, there's another Islamic topic going on in the world and it's called ''An Interview with Muhammed''.

I readt about it in the news and I do say, it got a point. The critic was that it would be another anti-Islamic propaganda video, but it's not. The reason why it isn't anti-Islamic is because it's just an interview with (a fake) Muhammed. Yes, he wears a paper mask, but that doesn't mean it's his face. It's just a neutral Islamic face with no stereotypical(?) details.

The author is called Ehsan Jami and he's an ex-muslim, so he knows the things about the Islam. He's interviewing the Islamic prophet called Muhammed, which you probally know already.

For your record, I haven't yet seen the interview completely, only parts from it. From my first opinion, it showed no anti-Islamic material, just like the news said.

Everyone alike, if you are an Athiest, Christian, Jew or Firelord21- I mean Muslim or Buddhist I don't care, tell us about your opinion on this.


Youtube videos are down here.

Mirror
Mirror


Note: All text above is a first opinion of mine, I might change it when I change my mind.
Note2: Critic and talking is allowed, just keep it to the topic and no flaming.

Discuss.


Oh and there's a new browsergame: Link.

 

[Gilles]

The person portraying Muhammad talks like Christopher Walken.

 

[Elenai]

The movie from an artistic standpoint was well made. And enjoyable in the aesthetic sense.

The content however was a rather mixed bag of nuts.

Some parts were good, and some parts were not so good, others were rather icky. On the whole however, I am allergic to nuts, so I found the thing to be rather sickening (taking into account that for Muslims, showing Muhammed in any form is a blasphemy, and realizing that I myself would not want to see Christ portrayed in a blasphemous manner)

 

[Vercas]

nice...what else could i say...lol?

 

[reza sword2]

I don't think the anti-islamic thingy that matters. As a Muslim, I think that portraying Muhammed's the problem. It goes against our religion to picture our prophet's faces (yes, we're not allowed to draw Jesus's face, cause he's one of our prophets as well). Same deal with pretending to be Muhammed or stuff like that. If people want to ask opinions about Islam, why not ask the wide Ismalic community?

Well, that's my quick opinion. (sorry haven't watched the vid, don't got time)

 

[Captain Griffen]

Islam's beliefs about saying stuff about profets, Islam or god are non-binding on non-Muslims. Anyone attempting to force it on others should by means other than use of their own freedom of expression (debate, etc.) should be arrested (as is the law - you cannot force things like that on people in a civilised nation).

 

[reza sword2]

That is true. Well I don't know. I'm not saying there shouldn't be pictures of Jesus and stuff like that. I'm just saying maybe that's causing the stirup. Well, I'm not exactly the right person to represent the wide Islam community. (I'm just a 14 year old hey)

 

[Captain Griffen]

What's causing a stirup is religions trying to force others to conform to their belief systems.

 

[Gilles]

Islam's beliefs about saying stuff about profets, Islam or god are non-binding on non-Muslims. Anyone attempting to force it on others should by means other than use of their own freedom of expression (debate, etc.) should be arrested (as is the law - you cannot force things like that on people in a civilised nation).

At the same time, my guess is the author of the video meant it to be a slap in the face to Islamic people, which is wrong. You should respect other peoples beliefs to an extent.

 

[The_wand_mirror]

nice...what else could i say...lol?

Holy crap this is boring.

 

[skrab]

The author is called Ehsan Jami and he's an ex-muslim, so he knows the things about the Islam.

just another idiot...

 

[The_wand_mirror]

just another idiot...

Oh yeah i forgot all muslims came from holland lol!

 

[skrab]

lol.

 

[Captain Griffen]

At the same time, my guess is the author of the video meant it to be a slap in the face to Islamic people, which is wrong. You should respect other peoples beliefs to an extent.

Why should I respect other people's beliefs? If for all x such that x is a belief, I should respect it, then I should respect the belief I should be killed. If you believe that isn't the case, then you don't believe beliefs should be respected.

If you do believe beliefs should be respected, then you should respect people's beliefs on beliefs, even if they themselves disrespectful of other beliefs, they are still beliefs.

 

[Mechanical Man]

How is called a bee in Arabian?

Muhamed.

(for who don't get it, in my language muha=fly, med=honey)

xD xD (sorry I just had to )

 

[Joe-black-5]

ftw my name is muhamed D: i am not a bee

 

[Hakeem]

If for all x such that x is a belief, I should respect it, then I should respect the belief I should be killed.

So long as nobody forces that belief on you, or others, what do you care?

 

[Captain Griffen]

So long as nobody forces that belief on you, or others, what do you care?

Why should you care if I don't respect your beliefs?

 

[Hakeem]

There is a difference between you not caring that I believe you should die and sending me a post card from your vacation saying "I'm alive and well."


Although it would be rather funny. XP

 

[Vercas]

rofl!
that's really funny