11:17, 8th Feb 2014
Sin'dorei300: U just added him a hood and made him grinning. It looks way too close to the original, make some more changes. I'll leave this pending.

Sin'dorei300: Approv'd.

work more on the helmet and I will give it a 3.5/5

3/5 for now

it's actually supposed to be a hood (cloth) I've updated the icon, I hope it's a bit better now.
Btw, I'm getting JPEG artefacts when generating icons with button manager... I don't know how to fix it, other than to make the icon manually ^^

thanks for the feedback and rating

I don't know... It looks cool, with the hood and all, but the hood is pretty blurry.
There's some chance that this can get rejected.

Am I mistaken or is this not the warcraft I warlock?



Seems like yours is just a recolored WarCraft III warlock and it since it doesn't really make a big difference I don't see this icon passing as useful either.

Yeah, it's supposed to go with a WC1 warlock model I put together that's based on the WC3 warlock. I also changed the mouth a bit

Hm, I should change the bit of the shoulders that's still visible, they're supposed to be covered I'll try to make it a bit less blurry tomorrow, calling it a night now.

If it gets rejected, well that's what the moderators are there for I guess

Razosh said:

Am I mistaken or is this not the warcraft I warlock?

Seems like yours is just a recolored WarCraft III warlock and it since it doesn't really make a big difference I don't see this icon passing as useful either.

Click to expand...

He didn't recolor it, he added a cloak and a smile to him.

My apology he did add a bit of stuff to it, still it's a very vaguely changed icon and I'm not sure it will succeed. But I've been wrong before.

That's alright I can't sleep so I worked on the icon a bit. It might still be a bit blurry? No longer has "naked" shoulders

Looks alright ingame to me

Seems usefull but i dislike the mask.

Could be useful, but i suggest to make it more unique. Not just cape. 3.5/5 for now

Maybe you should mess around with the mask near the hood, and change the beard a lil' bit? I would guess that would be enough changes. Maybe even change his eyecolor and teeth? That would look nice.

Yeah sounds good. I'm going to remove the mask from the matching model (don't like it either), maybe change/remove the beard, and then I'm going to update this icon accordingly. I may add some red highlighting to the mouth, but I'll see.

I think it'll be acceptable when I'm done with that

edit: mask has been removed

Cuz icons need at least 75% freehand and yours has less, it would be unfair for the other iconers to approve something like this.
Also, if an icon like this proves to be useful and highly downloaded, it'll be approved under the name of Blizzard Entertainment.

I think it's 75% freehand now. Only the lower part of the mouth and the beard is from the original icon.

But of course it's not up to me

BTN is still the same. The DISBTN is the only thing that is changed. Fix that dude.

Are you sure? It looks fine on my end. I'll reupload it anyway.
edit: done

edit again: cool, thanks for the approval! and for your patience

BTN is wrong again.

Try to do hard refresh (ctrl+F5), I don't see how it could have changed back? I definitely uploaded the latest version
I tried downloading it from the hive too, it looks fine when I open it

I see the author's been changed to Blizzard, that's fine I guess ^^

Well hell, this looks better.
Great job.

thanks!

It's nice and simple.

Glad you guys like it, I was worried it wouldn't be clear that it was supposed to be a staff in front of the warlock

Nice.

Look nice !