19:48, 25th Aug 2014
Sin'dorei300: Needs moar shading, and it's kinda too bright. Also, the glow blends with the cookie 2 much.

Reserved. Ctrl + F5

Cool, but I prefer the cake

I forgot an outline issue with the glow. Will fix tomorrow.

Did you add more milk powder so IT BECOMES SWEET!

On-Topic:
Voting for Approval(4/5) with followings:

• Glad to see updated ;D. Set to 4/5

Off-Topic:
I'm recuiting members for my group. Named ''Icon Reviewers Group'' and it's official(Maybe xD)!! I'm asked Ralle but we have only 2 members. We are required 6 or more members to create this!! Please help me!!

Awesome!!! Thanks so much CakeMaster, your awesome. =)

5/5 by the way.

Good for Cookie Monster

It seems out of place and doesn't really seem to go with the art style of many other icons here. That's just my 2cents.

actually, they look a little sharp but other than that
4/5 and
I'm gonna be sick, this is too sweet!!!!
and..... silly
anybody have a bucket,

Chocobo rider coming through

Strange but cool, 5/5

Best Icon ever 6/5 director's cut

the unswerving bias of the cookie lord has arrived. <3

Sweet mother of God, It's fitting for a Cookie Master!

On-Topic : a nice addition to sweets and sugar-coated cakes. You should use some rainbow background tough.. 4/5

Edit: I made some changes, added background
I think it looks much better with a background.

it's a cake, not a rainbow. Too bright, lacks shading..

Updated! Added shading. (this is weird)

Oh and sorry, I won't be adding a background.