15:08, 30th Apr 2009
Paladon: Well, a first try. I can't approve it at its current state.
I recommend you to pratice the use of shadings and highlights. Study some tutorials.

It needs more shading, more highlights, more everything. This is just a WIP. And it also needs a closer look.

EDIT: "Keeper20of20the20Grove20Icon" - what's up with that? :S

in my eyes i dont even think this icon deserves a revew so ill bee quick.
PROS
none
CONS
- it looks like you made it with paint and wasted 20 min of your time on it....
- Not a proper name (Keeper20of and so on)
- No significant description
MY RATING
1/5
REJECTED

FrIkY said:

It needs more shading, more highlights, more everything. This is just a WIP. And it also needs a closer look.

Click to expand...

Okay, I will try to fix that. I have alot of things to do so it will probobly be done in a week or so.

FrIkY said:

EDIT: "Keeper20of20the20Grove20Icon" - what's up with that? :S

Click to expand...

I don't know my friend (Grave_Digger_) helped me convert it. So I just took the thing files and attached them.

Dentothor said:

- it looks like you made it with paint and wasted 20 min of your time on it....

Click to expand...

Then what do u suggest I improve?

Dentothor said:

- Not a proper name (Keeper20of and so on)

Click to expand...

I will have that updated as soon as I fix the icon itself a little bit.

Dentothor said:

- No significant description

Click to expand...

I didn't have so much time so I didn't write it all down at that moment. I will fix that at the same time as i fix the name.

You know, I like it. It's very cartoonish. It doesn't fit with the WC3 theme, but its definately not useless. It does NOT suck. It just needs work, like with the border and shadings.
5/5 since the shortsighted peeps rated 1/5.

Dentothor, what the fuck is description for? I really dont like that people say in description "Give cerdits, dont edit etc.". So, I don't think that the icon will get approved for the quality, but, I do love that you as a "new" here did not ask for rep and credits.

Not useful at all, as a better one is already made. I can't see any shading, color variation or definition. Honestly, I could do something like this in merely a few minutes using Paint.

%20 is used to show a space, thats why. I say 2.5/5 for effort though.