In my humble opinion, this is a lovely icon and I would give it a rating of Highly Recommended.
@NFWar, your icons also don't feel warcraft at all, but that doesn't stop them from being lovely. I like your art very much, but yeah, it's no warcraft. You use too much of Dodge, which doesn't meet the WCIII standards in icons, but see, that's not a flaw you'd think, it's just your way of art.