Whispering Woods

[Moderator]

17:01, 10th Mar 2014
Hell_Master: Map approved with a rating of 4/5 based on eubz's short but straightforward review:

The Review:
You have created a nice melee map. The terrain is cool which uses a variety of tiles. Item drops fits with the creep level. You have used Terrain fog, custom weather, light and sound environment wisely. It has environmental doodads and neutral units to make the map alive. The best is that the map is symmetrical.

suggestion: You can add some green encampments more than red and orange. Green encampments are essential at the early stage of the game.

This map is in the state of approval with 4/5 rating because this mostly follows rules in creating a melee map as stated by kobas here

 

[taavidude]

Review: Whispering Woods
Good points
Fun gameplay
Huge map
Terrain is great
Bad points
None
Suggestions
None
5/5

 

[eubz]

The Review:
You have created a nice melee map. The terrain is cool which uses a variety of tiles. Item drops fits with the creep level. You have used Terrain fog, custom weather, light and sound environment wisely. It has environmental doodads and neutral units to make the map alive. The best is that the map is symmetrical.

suggestion: You can add some green encampments more than red and orange. Green encampments are essential at the early stage of the game.

This map is in the state of approval with 4/5 rating because this mostly follows rules in creating a melee map as stated by kobas here

 

[BLazeKraze]

Thanks for the good review .

 

[Oraien]

nice map, I like it, but I played it with my brother and we both were complaining about the pathing, it's just not right

 

[BLazeKraze]

nice map, I like it, but I played it with my brother and we both were complaining about the pathing, it's just not right

I preferred that, you must cut down trees, It ups to you ... The trees and small pathings have purpse, for scouting , shortcuts, ambushing etc .. Think about real forest ...

 

[Oraien]

I preferred that, you must cut down trees, It ups to you ... The trees and small pathings have purpse, for scouting , shortcuts, ambushing etc .. Think about real forest ...

its not only the trees, some of the waters were also unable to be passed

 

[Dess_26]

What I like about this map:
- terrain,
- neutrals,

What I don't like about this map:
- pathing (there is simply not enough space for 4 vs 4, especially in the center),
- neutral drops (creeps are too strong, drops are too weak),
- the lack of a health/mana fountain (now really, I would prefer a health fountain instead of that dragon shop),
- I find this map being HUGE, and despite of it's size, there is no way you can have a fair fight with that lack of space on the narrow paths...

 

[Thorin Oakenshield]

Love the map it was really fun to play on even against A.I.s great job!

 

[Totally not an Alien]

Like it a lot looks really beautifull