What would be the greatest strategy game of all time!

[MySpaceBarBroke]

A rush is when two players start out, one builds, say, a marine, then charges to the enemy base, the enemy has 0 people except workers, so you make the marine attack, then run when they come at you, then when they give up, you come back take a bunhca shots, then run when they attempt to defend themselves until they're all dead. War never has been and will never be like that, if it ever does...then all i can say is...wtf...

Betcha never heard of hit-and-run tactics.

 

[PurplePoot]

One SCV > One marine.

About resource hoarding, that would be like you saying WW2 was imba because Germany quickly claimed a lot of raw material sites such as Lorraine. Resource hoarding is easy to fight if you just pressure their expansions.

 

[Grade A Kill]

you missed my point...as usual, and my point is, units should come from off map, and that there should be no resources, and yet again you think im complaining about resources hording, when actually im saying its too unrealistic. and yeah ive heard of hit and run tactics, but not fire a shot, run come back fire a shot, run then comeback, fire a shot , run then comeback, rinse and repeat until you win...that is incredebly retarded.

and Germany did claimed alot of resources, but it doesn't mean victory no matter what, it all comes down to the decisions and moves you make out in the battle field. + extra resources mean they get a steady flow of tanks coming off of the asembly line, not extra tanks, not 2X more tanks just the same. when Germany claims oil, they now get a steady supply of feul, thats all, when the claim metal resources, they get a more steady flow of materials for tanks.

My whole idea is to make strategy games have more realistic combat, the tactical decisions and strategy, not resource hording because in any battle field, you cant just horde resources nad run because they are miles away, you gotta fight all the way there.

 

[MySpaceBarBroke]

you missed my point...as usual

And you're being a jackass, as usual.

and my point is, units should come from off map, and that there should be no resources, and yet again you think im complaining about resources hording, when actually im saying its too unrealistic. and yeah ive heard of hit and run tactics, but not fire a shot, run come back fire a shot, run then comeback, fire a shot , run then comeback, rinse and repeat until you win...that is incredebly retarded.

No, dude, you just suck at this game. Horribly. Those are hit-and-run tactics.

and Germany did claimed alot of resources, but it doesn't mean victory no matter what, it all comes down to the decisions and moves you make out in the battle field. + extra resources mean they get a steady flow of tanks coming off of the asembly line, not extra tanks, not 2X more tanks just the same. when Germany claims oil, they now get a steady supply of feul, thats all, when the claim metal resources, they get a more steady flow of materials for tanks.

And just where the hell is the fun in that?
People don't want to play a fucking game where you already have all the units. THAT WOULDN'T BE FUN. People want to see their army expand the way they built them.

My whole idea is to make strategy games have more realistic combat, the tactical decisions and strategy, not resource hording because in any battle field, you cant just horde resources nad run because they are miles away, you gotta fight all the way there.

You have no strategy if you're whining about that shit.

 

[WILL THE ALMIGHTY]

rushing can only be describe in a game, i cant explain how a rush would work in real life, i could say, its like two countries declare war on each other, one builds a stronger military faster and cahrges before the other one is ready...

... Worst example ever. Seriously.

 

[Slaytan]

STARCRAFT FUCKINGGG!!! RLZZZ!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! enough said ? u need more ??? huh ?

 

[Grade A Kill]

ok you know what...i just fucking give up, i'll make this game, and if you guys dont wanna play it, fine, your loss it will be. I dont even know what the hell were arguing about anyway, it went from artilery, to C&C3, to starcraft, to the Blitzkreig and to resource hording and only one guy ever said it probebly be a good game, everyone else never said anything about it, all you guys say is its ok to be able to capture someone elses construction yard instantly and sell it instantly...JUST WHAT THE FUCK DO YOU GUYS SEE IN STRATEGY GAMES...GOD DAMMIT >< !!! you guys have never even played a realistic strategy game how do you guys know its not fun, of course its fun, and it brings REAL LIFE TACTICS and strategies into the game. and what the fuck is wrong with real life tactics and strategies!!! seriusly, tell me why they are not OK, and selling your enemies command center is ok!!! tell me and then someone please fucking close this shit!!! i made it to find out if people think i have a good idea, and all i learned is people think a 2 Zergling rush is a fucking strategy and is realistic!

 

[Grade A Kill]

And you're being a jackass, as usual.

No, dude, you just suck at this game. Horribly. Those are hit-and-run tactics.

And just where the hell is the fun in that?
People don't want to play a fucking game where you already have all the units. THAT WOULDN'T BE FUN. People want to see their army expand the way they built them.

You have no strategy if you're whining about that shit.

holy fucking god and you say i have no sense of strategy, if you were to play a realistic strategy game you'ld die 2 minutes in the game when you try to go command and conquer style on a fairly well fortified position with an army 1/2 the size of yours. a hit and run is like with planes, fly in, bomb something then get out there, not use a marine or two, attack, run until your persuers give up, comeback fire a shot, run then comeback, that is fucking bullshit, BULLSHIT I SAY!!!!!!! and you think, whats wrong with that? EVERYTHING GOD DAMMIT ><!!! EVERYTHING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

how do you close a thread?

 

[Grade A Kill]

... Worst example ever. Seriously.

yeah that was my fucking point...you cant give an example in real life because THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS A RUSH IN REAL LIFE WARFARE!!!

 

[Grade A Kill]

before either someone closes this for me or i figure out if i can, someone please explain to me what the hell is wrong with realistic combat in a strategy game, someone please just tell that to me, you never ever ever did explain why you dont like realism.

hey purple poot, your a forum modderator, close this for me, after explaining whats wrong with realistic combat.

 

[Slaytan]

bwhahahahhaha such a funny thread XDDD you guys make me LMFAO

 

[PurplePoot]

I don't have power over this forum. If you want this thread closed PM ZypherXII, Shados, or Mecheon (Or any other Global Mod/Admin, but those are the people that generally moderate Off-Topic).

 

[frostwhisper]

I don't know which is more annoying in this case:
Grade A Kill's pissed off whimpering or Slaytan's continuous retarded spam...

 

[Slaytan]

I don't know which is more annoying in this case:
Grade A Kill's pissed off whimpering or Slaytan's continuous retarded spam...

both maybe

but i LMAO when hes said " fuck i just give up .. or .. holy fck.. --- u say i have no sense for strategy. " hahahahhaahah

 

[Grade A Kill]

what is wrong with realism in strategy games?

 

[Mecheon]

what is wrong with realism in strategy games?

It won't sell as much compared to unrealistic strategy games

I mean, seriously, you even admitted it'd be slow paced earlier. You overestimate how much patience gamers have. They want instant results, they want systems that look both complex and simple at the same time, and, above all, they don't want to take too much time to do something

Unrealistic strategy games drop realism for fun. And when push comes to shove, that's all anyone really cares about if they're buying games

Personally, looking over your entire thing, my main criticisms are that it is overly complex and the varying factors are all pretty much a slave to realism. Also, making a highly complex AI system that takes in all those factors in an RTS setting where you control large groups of units... Yeah, good luck with that