This is a good idea for a model, but this particular version needs some work. Other people who commented on this really need to actually download and use the model before they comment or rate it, instead of just looking at the screenshot.
A corpse displays behind the archer for almost all his animations (Stand 2, Stand 3, Stand Hit, and Death are the only animations without this problem). Also, when he dies, near by units tend to sprout his bow and quiver. The archer also has no portrait. Most people apparently don't care about this, but since I'm stating personal opinion here, to me the lack of a portrait always makes the model seem fundamentally incomplete. It's particularly glaring in this case just cause the model is basically just a villager with new animations and attachments.
Anyway, I'd rate it 5/5 if the issues with this model were fixed, but as it is the model is basically unusable. =/