The Cold War v1.7

[Moderator]

19:26, 3rd Aug 2010
ap0calypse: Rejected

 

[Acutesharpness]

The Cold War is a game of 8 players(4 on each team) controlling a platoon (5 food limit) on an objective to destroy the opposing base. The battlefield is a small area where players will directly send their units to damage the base or retreat to heal.

The game is pretty much like footmen frenzy, just a little nerfed and slow paced.

I had tried this map in single player and find it boring. It is due to lack of players. Since there is no custom races, the balancing for units should be okay.

_________________
I found a bug with hotkey of Rockets, hope you do check the rest.
I suggest to allow more terrain work as for a 4v4, the terrain is obviously to small.
I also suggest to increase the starting food limit(Wondering if there is a way, currently, to increase food limit)

Temporary Ratings(2/5)
I think it is unfair to rate it now because I hope for further improvements, the version is still early, may be in time to come, a new and well made RTS. Keep up the perserverance. I will be reviewing it again.

 

[Vengeancekael]

Improve the description, add bold titles, colorize the text, add spaces between each sentence, noone is going to read it like that. You can use colors etc. by writing the text in a comment box.

 

[Newominus]

When Infantry die, thier head just floats in the air, its creepy. Also you didnt change the name of some of the upgrades... Its the cold war and people have dragonhide armor???

 

[Yabooer]

Sheesh, Vengeancekael is any description good enough for you lol? Just screwing around with you, just see every game with you asking for a better description. Keep up the great work +rep!

Work on typos please and thank you.

Its the cold war and people have dragonhide armor???

Lol.

Will test some time.

 

[gangu]

hey can you give me the name of the soviet union hero skin?

 

[BlinkforFear]

Its the cold war and people have dragonhide armor???

dragon hide is a type of bulletproof armor... so if this is a present...(technically in the past since it is over but you know what i mean) day cold war game as in USA vs USSR then yes that is perfectly fine

 

[Bg_Trinnin]

Actually my map isnt based on "USA vs USSR", "The Cold War" is just a name.

 

[BlinkforFear]

well it says its a modern warfare map so i think it still works?

 

[Bg_Trinnin]

I suppose it does

 

[tastywater]

Send in the suicide tank for some free lumber Pretty nice map gonna test it online, lots of typos though .
Just an idea:
There could spawn loot here and there over the map which will give lumber when taken. This could add a more tactical situation if applied correctly. Just an idea

 

[ap0calypse]

Sheesh, Vengeancekael is any description good enough for you lol? <blablabla>

He's right though...

Rejected (until updated)
Reason: improve the description (fix all the typo's as well, let someone proof-read it).

 

[Newominus]

And seriously though, when making a description about your map DON'T use "u" or "tipes". Use "you" and "types".

 

[light bolt30]

I didn't really like the gameplay, sorry.. to me gets boring pretty quickly and there isn't anything interesting or new in these types of map genre.

 

[ap0calypse]

And seriously though, when making a description about your map DON'T use "u" or "tipes". Use "you" and "types".

This.
(aka: improve the description, yet again )

 

[Bg_Trinnin]

Is the description good enough now?

 

[lol_lam3r1]

Food Increase time too slow make it faster and more food at start and it would b nice =D

 

[Vengeancekael]

Not really, you should really colorize the text and add bold titles...
You can do so, by writing the description in a normal comment box, then copy&pasting it into the map description box when updating the map.

 

[Bg_Trinnin]

If u tell me the description isnt good enough now, i will go crazy

 

[Garfield1337]

i will go crazy

Aren't you already? *kidding ofc*

Well,map needs much improvement. Combat is a bit boring,armies just fight as in ordinary melee maps,there should be more tactic options in battles.
Maybe adding something like precision to units,like the farther the units from their target are,the less accurate they will be - this can be done by using curse buff with several levels. Also you can add some artillery units,that can be used to get enemy out of trenches with machine guns.
Commander's abilities aren't custom and are lame. You could add some atleast easy triggered spells such as...for example "Air strike", bombs fall from sky to designated area and damaging both allied and enemy units.

 

[bureaulamp]

Wow this map is 1.1x better then a melee map

 

[-Kobas-]

As map review member I am helping map moderators to clean THW!
I won't post any kind of review just final mark that will be Rejection or Approval!

I checked your map and I will vote for: Rejection

If you want to know more PM me and I will explain my vote