The flute. Or because of DotA, it's more commonly known as the "quarterstaff".
Honestly I feel like cheating by submitting this model. It's a bloody cylinder with the icon as texture. The stars and animation is from the other objects I made. Took me 20 minutes to "make" this one. But it needed to be made so here it is.
Keywords:
Flute, Staff, Stick, wood, recorder, quarter, Donatello