Skull Seige

[Moderator]

[APPROVED]
10th Mar 2008
Congrats 2nd Place Winner!

Mesh: (13/15)
Very good overall, but too flat and broad in some parts. The skull from the top or front view looked oddly shaped, but has a sick design otherwise.

Animations: (10/10)
All the animations were natural looking, no static animations, very, very well done overall.

Textures: (8/10)
Very creative use of the ingame textures, although some were a bit stretched, and use two sided materials!

Mechanics: (4/5)
Worked perfectly ingame, I have no complaints but one. The portrait camera was slightly off, and it chopped off the head a little.

Effects: (2/5)
I really wish you could have gotten some particles to work, because this model really could have used them at some place or another.

Creativity: (5/5)
Very cool idea, execution of mesh, animation, use of textures, and ideas were all superb.

Total: (42/50)

Nice job!
5/5
--donut3.5--

 

[Direfury]

Personally,I like it.

 

[varsaigen]

i dont really like it. It looks too basic. A flatbed cart with 2 wheels and a Huge skull on top is what I see. doesn't look good.

 

[Warhunter]

ye I agree varsaigen. But what are this model for??

 

[NatDis]

This model shows that the creature is actually bound to the vehicle so that it does not need front wheels to balance it.
Pros:-
Wonderful concept! +rep
Marvellous use of ingame textures.
Nice animations.
Impressive mesh design.

Cons:-
No details at all for the interior of the skull.
The stud of one of the tyres twitches strangely during the walk animation.
Portrait does not look so good. It would be better if it either showed the entire model or focussed on the head.

Extra:-
I do not see any need for particle or ribbon effects. This would be a perfect model if the above cons would be fixed. I am sad that there are few models of this kind. This is a wonderful model! All are recommended to use it in undead maps.

4.5/5

 

[Devine]

good but only 2wheels?

 

[kommunist]

good job

 

[TheDivineBoss]

W-
T-
F-

IS THAT? O.O

Awesome

 

[NinjaDino]

hmmm, not bad but i agree with warhunter and guy above him, too basic
but its still a good model, is it made from infernal machine or something like that?? 3/5
smart using of ingame txtures

 

[Choas name]

0/5 the Skull looks very big.

 

[D a w n]

0/5 the Skull looks very big.

before you post "crit" like this you should think about:

1.) that it is a lot of work to create a model
2.) that the creators of the models only do them for fun
3.) that you should give some real reasons why this model deserves 0/5



personally I think this model deserves a 4/5 because the concept is great, good use of ingame textures, the animations are good, fits the spirit of wc3 but the only thing that I don´t like that much is the portrait

 

[Choas name]

before you post "crit" like this you should think about:

1.) that it is a lot of work to create a model
2.) that the creators of the models only do them for fun
3.) that you should give some real reasons why this model deserves 0/5

i think your too soft

 

[frostwhisper]

i think your too soft

I encourage you to keep this up.
Only say your prayers while doing so.

 

[Kimbo]

i think your too soft

I suggest you post real comments instead of spam before I take action.

 

[Ordworse]

I think it's a good model! nice work, Werewulf! 4.5/5

 

[Lord_T]

I like it! Just the bottom of the front looks a tad stretched... think you could fix that?

 

[Capcy]

0/5 the Skull looks very big.

A few words, learn to give constructive criticism! Also;

YOUR A USELESS TOOL.. PISS OFF..

Got the point?

---

It's a well-thought-out model, I didn't download and look at it because I'm too damn lazy. Though, from the picture, it is a good model that deserves a 4/5 for appearances.

Good job wulf.

 

[TheGodOfIron]

An excellent model when it comes to its animation. Smooth and original, but it looks kinda starnge to me. This model, does it only have 2 wheels? Could make the front wheel more obvious to make it look more realistic. But good job werewulf, congratulations to you for winning the Second Place.
And Choas Name, please don't cause any more trouble, I hate when the Hiveworskshop goes upside down because of one man.

 

[Kimbo]

...TheGodOfIron..stop double or stack posting, its ticking me off that I have to clean it up.

 

[TheGodOfIron]

...TheGodOfIron..stop double or stack posting, its ticking me off that I have to clean it up.

Erm what is stack posting? Sorry for double posting, I have cut down on it.

 

[inverted]

very nice, i love it

 

[Ravager]

I like it alot. Its very basic, but it still makes a good siege unit for the scourge. Good job Werewulf!

 

[HorizonTal]

It really looks a lot like the "Donna rachele", but I doubt you know what I'm talking about.

 

[NatDis]

This model, does it only have 2 wheels?

Werewulf's creativity is astounding. The model has 2 wheels only to show that the monster is actually linked to the cart and can lift itself up to move.

 

[HappyCockroach]

Thats such a cute model 5/5

 

[Deleted member 219079]

This is totally unique, great job (I really hope commenting on dead old resources won't be counted as necro posting lol)

 

[Moises08x]

Excellent model