Rise Of Evil

[Moderator]

01:09, 25th Mar 2013
Orcnet: see my commentary

 

[Daffa]

Please tell us the Gameplay, Credits, Etc. about the map, this map description must be improved, check below

EDIT : I edit this post every time I give comment for this map, unless necessary for me for other post

Overall, use the Map Description Template to create your description

Here is the link to get the description templates : http://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums/miscellaneous-tutorials-456/map-description-templates-171659/

I will play this map later, since its 5AM the time I write the post, and I am busy, expect feedback from me on my next post )
I will rate the map 2/5 for now, but it will change on my next post

Regards,

Daffa the Mage

 

[Tommynator77]

Thanks for your feedback already
I hope you like my map

 

[Daffa]

Map Review - On Request

Daffa the Mage Map Review :

Terrain :
The Terrain are normal, nothing exciting
Score : 2.5/5

Spells :
Boring Old Spells, make some new spells, better if you trigger them
Score : 0.5/5

Units :
Notes : without looking at the editor, I can see that Fulbolg Ranger
The Units have one issue :
-Fulbolg Ranger has Mana, he didn't need it
Also, maybe add more unit ?
And use some costum model, search it at Hive Models
Score : 0.8/5

Gameplay :
Just a normal melee map with costum AI and well the cinematic is place properly though
Score : 2.2/5

Replayable :
Its not very exciting, makes it not very replayable
Score : 0.7/5

Overall :
Its a good map, but it still lacking in many things, this map is good, just need more polishing, if this meant to be a chapter from a big campaign, I highly advise you make all the chapter first then upload it.

Total Score : 6.7/25

Converted Score : 1.34/5 Unacceptable - Vote for Rejection


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Suggestion :
this map needs lot of improvements, as following :
-Unit should have some custom models.
-Unit should have custom abilities
-Add more variation for the terrain
-AI Heroes in Campaign (only if this meant you planned to use this as a campaign) never lvl Up

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Score Table :

0.0-1.5 = Unacceptable - Vote for Rejection
1.6-2.3 = Lacking - Vote for Rejection
2.4-2.7 = Lacking - Vote for Approval
2.8-3.4 = Acceptable - Vote for Approval
3.5-4.2 = Recommended - Vote for Approval
4.3-4.7 = Highly Recommended - Vote for Approval and Recommended Map Section
4.8-5.0 = Director's Cut - Vote for Approval and Director Cut Map Section
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Second Request : If you wish me to re scored your map a second time please PM thank you.

 

[Tommynator77]

Thank you for your feedback, I will try to make a complete campaign first and upload it after I will also try to keep you comments in mind when creating the next chapters.

 

[Daffa]

Your welcome

 

[Orcnet]

this map is very simple and lacks enough game play morely it is a Altered Melee vs Melee sort of game, but the dialogue of each character is decent, the lack of ground, doodads, space and melee standards makes the game very monotone, if you do wish to continue this please proceed in the Map Development thread for more improvement and feed back good day then