Moderator
M
Moderator
13:07, 17th Apr 2009 by bounty hunter2:
Three votes for rejection clearly state this map is too low of quality, Rejected.
Three votes for rejection clearly state this map is too low of quality, Rejected.
(4 ratings)
No, they cant due to it's quality. Your map is equal to pretty not done project.Its not finished but i think administrator or moderators can upload DEMO too...
Basic
- This isn't an ORPG, but an RPG (know the difference, don't call your map an ORPG)
- When you reach lvl 5, levelling goes extremely slow (neutral hostile isn't recommended).
- No description
- Flat terrain, repetitive doodads, half of the terrain is just... empty, city isn't appealing (blizzard cliffs for walls, not realistic)
- There is only 1 item? The only way to get that item is to finish a quest, of which you don't even know it exists
- What is the point of the map? There are no bosses (or is The Forgotten One a boss?)
Objects
- You can only "choose" 1 hero - he doesn't even have custom spells
- No Custom spells (as said before)
- Most units haven't been changed (like your hero)
- The only item there is isn't even modified (the "Letter" doesn't count as an item ;p)
Terrain
- Flat terrain
- Repetitive Doodads
- City doesn't look good: blizzard cliffs for walls, not realistic
Triggers
- very poor triggering
- There is a quest! How do we know that? Where is the forest Shadow? (I've found him after a fery long while)
- No leaks, very good...
If you looked at the name of the map it's still a beta map and he's just showing what hes got so far n so that makes it a demo, instead of rude comments try to help him instead of making him feel bad.
Keep working hard rokis202, just try to improve on the things people type/say.
Rules
You may not submit maps which:
The map description must:
- Are of an extremely poor quality (Maps deemed to be so by the Maps Moderation team will be removed),
- Be in English,
- Be well written, and
- Give a general overview of the map contents, not necessarily revealing any detail of the story/lore.
If you looked at the name of the map it's still a beta map and he's just showing what hes got so far n so that makes it a demo, instead of rude comments try to help him instead of making him feel bad.
Keep working hard rokis202, just try to improve on the things people type/say.
I'll follow APproject...
Rating: 1/5Triggers
- No leaks, very good...
Not Approved
If you looked at the name of the map it's still a beta map and he's just showing what hes got so far n so that makes it a demo, instead of rude comments try to help him instead of making him feel bad.
Keep working hard rokis202, just try to improve on the things people type/say.
Extremely rude comment said:Terrain - The terrain was absolutely terrible and a complete bullshit. 60-70% of the map terrain was empty with nothing at it.
Scripting/Triggering - The trigger was suck and badly done. Who the fuck called you to use Action - Do Nothing for a If/Then/Else multiple function? This useless trigger was just calling another action that does partically nothing. The only usefulness of it was for If/Then/Else single function. It even have memory leak such as player group and region leak.
Description - Terrible, awful and bad. It doesn't give a indepth detail about it and look like it was scribble by a 1 years old baby.
Gameplay/Replayability - Boring and awful, just a piece of shit.
This look like a piece of dumbshit that was make in 10 minutes, my dog could have done better.
Constructive Critism said:Terrain - The terrain was poorly develop, with most of the terrain being empty with the lack of tiles variation, destructible/doodad usage. The creep was seems to be randomly generate and place around the map.
Scripting/Triggering - Although it seems like you optimize the map, but it still isn't at top performance. It leak player group and region (Region leak occur at Castle and Castle Att files).
Try not to use Action - Do Nothing as the only purpose of this trigger was for If/Then/Else single function.
Description - The description was way too simple and doesn't provide enough detail to user. You need to make a indepth detail about it.
Even the description at this site need improvement as well. Try make your map sound more interesting, what makes it better than other map and so on.
Gameplay/Replayability - It seems like you use origin hero and spell for hero defensive genre map. They doesn't suit this kind of genre and the gameplay seems to be repetitive, the spawn timer need improvement as well.
This map quality was way to low to be acceptable. It seems to be a alpha version map with barely 30% completion done. Even if it was a demo, it should be at least 70-90% to complete the entire phase of alpha stage.
1/5 from me and vote for disapprove.
Thanks who helped me... sorry... but how i fix extreemely poor quality?