Map approval status disappeared

[Kitabatake]

I just noticed that the approval status of my map has disappeared!

]==The New World==[ 4.0c - The Hive Workshop - A Warcraft III Modding Site

The map was approved about a year ago, but now all of a sudden the review is gone and the approval status as well.

 

[Rui]

That was me. I removed it due to the untrustworthy review that was made. The status of your map have been set to Reviewed for the time being.
I will consider having a minimod play it and evaluate it, and since it has a good number of ratings and downloads, there's a good chance it'll get approved again.

 

[Aeroblyctos]

I removed it due to the untrustworthy review that was made.

An "untrustworthy review", ehh? What are you saying? Read the review again that was:

This map is quite well designed with cool features such as using houses to increase your income, which is used to repersent population, harvesting wood with your workers, and upgrading buildings to advance your culture. You have to use research in order to advance your armaments and what you can use depends on what you have researched. The sea battles seem to be a little lopsided in favor of juggernaughts when I played.

I give "The New World" a 8 out of 10.

By saying this is untrustworthy review you also mean that this is not good review enough. Panther-anthro is well-know old member of the hive and I think he's reviews are enough. Also, it have almost 20k download and good rating in hive.

Doesn't hive already have problems of "too many maps"? I think it's waste of time to review again maps like this one. It's just a lot more work, because reviewing this map for example should take at least 1 hour to test everything.

The status of your map have been set to Reviewed for the time being.

Very well then, I hope this will be done then soon.

I will consider having a minimod play it and evaluate it, and since it has a good number of ratings and downloads, there's a good chance it'll get approved again.

Of course it will be approved. There isn't any "chance", it will be approved.


After all, I know that you are one of the most hardworking mods here and I respect that. But I think unapproving this map was a wrong move. I hope we come come to terms by approving this map soon.

 

[Rui]

An "untrustworthy review", ehh? What are you saying? Read the review again that was:

This map is quite well designed with cool features such as using houses to increase your income, which is used to repersent population, harvesting wood with your workers, and upgrading buildings to advance your culture. You have to use research in order to advance your armaments and what you can use depends on what you have researched. The sea battles seem to be a little lopsided in favor of juggernaughts when I played.

I give "The New World" a 8 out of 10.

By saying this is untrustworthy review you also mean that this is not good review enough. Panther-anthro is well-know old member of the hive and I think he's reviews are enough. Also, it have almost 20k download and good rating in hive.

It's not even a review, you know. It's a description of the map, and a rating. That is fine as long as it gets your map approved.

panther-anthro is well-known for other reasons. Plus, he's not "old". He comes and goes as he damn well pleases, and that doesn't happen only in the Hive. Either way, it's irrelevant.

(...)
Of course it will be approved. There isn't any "chance", it will be approved.
(...)

Very confident of that you seem to be. I don't advice demanding anything, you are in no position to do so.

(...) But I think unapproving this map was a wrong move. (...)

Your map was not unapproved.

 

[Aeroblyctos]

Your map was not unapproved.

It's mine & Kita's map. We both made it.

 

[Vicboy]

If I we're you Aero, I'd be happy...

Because it "hopefully" gives an opportunity for a more in-depth and attractive review. The review made by that guy wasn't really one... Nor is it even making me want to download it... Just relax or ask someone you'd like to review it to.

Oh, and how is that Fireball thingy I helped you going?

You trashed it didn't you ^_^...

Sigh... Goodnight

 

[Aeroblyctos]

Because it "hopefully" gives an opportunity for a more in-depth and attractive review. The review made by that guy wasn't really one... Nor is it even making me want to download it... Just relax or ask someone you'd like to review it to.

Yeah, you have a good point. I'm waiting curiously how someone is going to review this map again. Actually, Kitabatake is coming tomorrow to my home and we are going to update the campaign and put some more stuff into it.

Oh, and how is that Fireball thingy I helped you going?

Fire ball? Off-topic?

You trashed it didn't you ^_^...

Whoooooat?

Sigh... Goodnight

Well, goodnight to you too.

 

[Septimus]

I already check the sources, it doesn't seems to be bugged along my inspection evem though I did not fully test the entire function.

And the quality ? yes, it is acceptable.

Do not worry, I am quite strict in checking bug. So, any sources earn my approval could be consider quite safe from fatal error or crash.

 

[PurplePoot]

Here's a review of your map in two words: Massively imbalanced.

I played it once before, and the balance was horrible. It wasn't the first-time-noob sort of stuff, it was blatantly obvious. Admittedly I haven't played it in a month or so, but I doubt it's fixed that if it was left there for so long.

 

[D.I.Y Death]

Here's a review of your map in two words: Massively imbalanced.

I played it once before, and the balance was horrible. It wasn't the first-time-noob sort of stuff, it was blatantly obvious. Admittedly I haven't played it in a month or so, but I doubt it's fixed that if it was left there for so long.

Could you be a little more specific? That way its not complaining and its feedback.

 

[PurplePoot]

I should think it would be relatively obvious, but the highest-tier knights were unstoppable by anything other than the highest-tier knights.

 

[D.I.Y Death]

I should think it would be relatively obvious, but the highest-tier knights were unstoppable by anything other than the highest-tier knights.

Ive never played the game before. I was just reading this through and wanted to help the creator out. Thanks for explaining. Hopefully he/she can improve on their map now.

 

[Aeroblyctos]

We are actually improving it all the time. Any feedback is welcome.

 

[TKF]

That's why some additional pages of unapproved maps was increased suddenly. I thought it was hive bug.


I found it weird here
Battle Tanks 8.54b - The Hive Workshop - A Warcraft III Modding Site

I though it haven't been approved yet, but I was wrong