Forest Duel v1.0

[Moderator]

Orcnet

21:12, 15th Oct 2013

---

Forest Duel (Tested Version 1.0) Rate Score Percent Letter 5/5 91-100 A Rate Score Percent Letter 4/5 81-90% B Rate Score Percent Letter 3/5 75-80% C Rate Score Percent Letter 2/5 70-74% D Rate Score Percent Letter 1/5 50-69% F Overview: Gameplay "Creep difficulty needs to tone down its level and value because the map is only good for a 1 on 1 match and does not need to make the game longer to tackle and so fort. The global area for the map doesn't need goblin laboratories so instead a mercenary camp would do, yet the map can still be appreciated in its current execution, if you will follow my suggestions the ratings could get better." Terrain "The map's design view is very basic looking and does not appeal in both Blizzard's designing or much of a custom environmental look, I suggest you extract more jungle looking theme for the map as well on lowering the water levels to make it shallow, it would be bad looking for a jungle that has an island look on it." Management "Overall can be useful, if you have read my suggestions for the game play and terrain categories, things might change in state of view." Total Score: (Gameplay[x/5] + Terrain[x/5] + Management[x/5] / Total Score[15] * 50 + 50) Rate Score Percent Letter 8/15 77% C

 

[Doomguy80]

Looks pretty fun! I like how it looks and will review it later.

 

[Daffa]

The Base looks monotone, I suggest to place Red's Base on the Northeastern Goldmine instead. Also, I suggest to fill the Southeast and Northwest Zones (unless there are creeps in it) with something.

 

[Twilight]

Looks pretty fun! I like how it looks and will review it later.

OK I will w8 for review

The Base looks monotone, I suggest to place Red's Base on the Northeastern Goldmine instead. Also, I suggest to fill the Southeast and Northwest Zones (unless there are creeps in it) with something.

Thanks for suggestion, but I like the placement of Player 1 (red) start loc, but still thanks for suggestion, and I will decorate the southeast and northwest zones, I dident work on that much, I will update. +rep (Give me time to spread)

 

[Legal_Ease]

Twilight, you are a machine! You are producing nice quality maps at an alarming rate. I'm worried, are you sleeping enough? JK, sleep is for sissies. Anyway, looks great! Good quality but it's a bit flat. More variation in terrain height would look nice. Even Echo Islands has a lot of raised terrain. Other than that I think it looks great!

I would have put the taverns in the SE and NW corners, but thats just me. They seem a bit close to the creeps.

 

[Twilight]

Twilight, you are a machine! You are producing nice quality maps at an alarming rate. I'm worried, are you sleeping enough? JK, sleep is for sissies. Anyway, looks great! Good quality but it's a bit flat. More variation in terrain height would look nice. Even Echo Islands has a lot of raised terrain. Other than that I think it looks great!

I would have put the taverns in the SE and NW corners, but thats just me. They seem a bit close to the creeps.

Thanks, I don't sleep at all, even when I lie on my bead I can't shut my eyes down. Anyway thanks for suggestions I will improve the map. +rep

 

[FUJI]

I don't see any bugs in this game ! Maybe adding some water doodads make it beautiful but it's okay even none ^^ and Legal_Ease is right add some terrain heights so it will looks more cool!!!. That's all I can say. 4/5 +Reputation Points!

 

[Rheiko]

Twilight, you are a machine! You are producing nice quality maps at an alarming rate. I'm worried, are you sleeping enough? JK, sleep is for sissies

not really, sleep is one of my hobbies :3

v1.0
-Relesed

Released*

and as legal_ease said, more variation in terrain height would be nice
i rate it 4/5

 

[Twilight]

I don't see any bugs in this game ! Maybe adding some water doodads make it beautiful but it's okay even none ^^ and Legal_Ease is right add some terrain heights so it will looks more cool!!!. That's all I can say. 4/5 +Reputation Points!

Thanks dude I will improve the terrain +rep

not really, sleep is one of my hobbies :3


Released*

and as legal_ease said, more variation in terrain height would be nice
i rate it 4/5

OK I will use more variation +rep

 

[BLazeKraze]

I glad to say that there's many people making melee maps . Because most of warcraft 3 players love to play custom maps .
Your map was good but I saw some imbalance .

Comments and Suggestions

-In placing taverns, You should put it to another place because its too near to goldmine with guards . I know that the creeps can't attack the buying units or hero when try to buy heroes, But these are not good enough . You may put 1 tavern in some isolated place . (in my own thoughts) . The path of another place is too tight . Fix them .
-In terrain management, The terrain is too flat, You may use height tools for putting some small hills or any thing that may look the terrain not flat .
-In creeps , I don't see any problem regarding on item drops .
-Some places are too empty . You put mix tile very well but I suggest that you should put shrubs or any forest stuffs . Add more decoration make the map great .
-In the river side, try to decorate them, Put some cattail, Lily, rocks etc . I know that these doodads has no role in game play , But remember, map with good terrain appearance is more enjoyable .

Rating : Cool map . 3/5
XD keep up to make a good work .

 

[Twilight]

Thanks for review, I will do all these things +rep

 

[Orcnet]

Map approved by its current version, see moderator comment.

 

[Rheiko]

orcnet, where's your tabs tag.. ?
huge review you have there

 

[Twilight]

Thanks orcent for approval +rep

 

[Orcnet]

orcnet, where's your tabs tag.. ?
huge review you have there

Its better this way.

Thanks orcent for approval +rep

No prob.