Dragon's Hill

[Moderator]

Orcnet

19:53, 31th May 2013

Comment

Review

Map Approved

Dragon's Hill (No Version/s Stated) Rate Score Percent Letter 5/5 91-100 A Rate Score Percent Letter 4/5 81-90% B Rate Score Percent Letter 3/5 75-80% C Rate Score Percent Letter 2/5 70-74% D Rate Score Percent Letter 1/5 50-69% F Overview: Gameplay "Dragon's Hill" is a 4 player melee map on a medium sized map. "Game play is great, no much problems found as well as the neutral buildings and creep difficulty is fine. Same goes to the expansion and middle raid part." Terrain "Terrain is very decent, no much problems found for now." Management "To finalize my review, this is a good map for melee lovers, both game-wise and terrain view." Total Score: Rate Score Percent Letter 12/15 90% B

 

[Orcnet]

map approved, see details on top :>

 

[normalice]

I'll give some feedback, since I'm here:
the good
-terrain looks fine
-sufficient space and creeps for a good game.

the bad
-insufficient resources. Particularly in a FFA or 2v2 game, all players are going to run out of gold really fast. Additionally, the number of trees at the starting location are a bit too few.
-furblongs that are part of the central red camps drop a random 'level 4 item.' This includes the miscellaneous items "ring of the archmagi," which is a bit imbalanced as far as items go.

the quirks
-creeps at natural expansions and at unused starting locations are set to the 'campaign' aggro range. Not a big deal since there is plenty of space, but it is uncommon.
-saytr camps on the edges of the map have no drops. also not a big deal, but also uncommon.

suggestions
-you have no level 3 items dropping anywhere. I would suggest changing one of your level 4 drops to a level 3 drop.

 

[RCS12]

I'll give some feedback, since I'm here:
the good
-terrain looks fine
-sufficient space and creeps for a good game.

the bad
-insufficient resources. Particularly in a FFA or 2v2 game, all players are going to run out of gold really fast. Additionally, the number of trees at the starting location are a bit too few.
-furblongs that are part of the central red camps drop a random 'level 4 item.' This includes the miscellaneous items "ring of the archmagi," which is a bit imbalanced as far as items go.

the quirks
-creeps at natural expansions and at unused starting locations are set to the 'campaign' aggro range. Not a big deal since there is plenty of space, but it is uncommon.
-saytr camps on the edges of the map have no drops. also not a big deal, but also uncommon.

suggestions
-you have no level 3 items dropping anywhere. I would suggest changing one of your level 4 drops to a level 3 drop.

Ok Gotta Update that later kinda busy today

 

[RCS12]

Added Screenshots =)

 

[Legal_Ease]

Very nice looking terrain. I want to see more screenshots though.

I'll download when I get home and rate it after playing it. +1 rep for now.

 

[RCS12]

Very nice looking terrain. I want to see more screenshots though.

Is this really a "hero arena?" It looks like a Melee map. I'll download when I get home and rate it after playing it. +1 rep for now.

Thanks. BTW it's a melee map.

 

[Legal_Ease]

The terrain is too flat, it could use some height variation and maybe some doodads. Its decent and spaced well. Creeps are balanced. I find nothing actually wrong with this map but it lacks anything spectacular too. 4/5. Very playable, thoughtfully made. It has a nice feel to it. It doesn't look like anything from Blizzard.

 

[RCS12]

The terrain is too flat, it could use some height variation and maybe some doodads. Its decent and spaced well. Creeps are balanced. I find nothing actually wrong with this map but it lacks anything spectacular too. 4/5. Very playable, thoughtfully made. It has a nice feel to it. It doesn't look like anything from Blizzard.

Thanks for your rating and sorry for late reply, I'm always busy at home.