My Ratings value
5/5 for Perfect
4/5 for Really Good
3/5 for Good
2/5 for Fair
1/5 for Bad
0/5 for Horrible
For Overall Rating:
15 - 20 for Perfect/Excellent
10 - 15 for Really Good/Fair
05 - 10 for Bad/No fun
00 - 05 for Horrible/Disgusting
Story:-, no need to rate the story, since the map is based on the diablo 3 gameplay trailer.
Quests:-, not gonna rate the quests, since there's just one objective.
Combat:4/5, the combat is alot of fun, along with the powerful items, but it misses the hack'n slash style, but i'm sure you will be improving it alot
Sounds/effects/skills/Models/Skins:3.5/5, well the models are simply gorgeous, along with the effects and diablo music&sounds, but the spells....They're not the ones that were revealed. But the_silent is working on them, so i guess they will be added, soon.
Terrain:5/5, the terrain is just director's cut, Cloudwolf clearly is the best terrainer who i know. And everytime you update the map, you change the whole terrain, which is a plus
Gameplay/Fun factor3/5, well i guess it can be fun, when played with several other people, but the balance system makes the game extremely easy when there's just one player in the game. But the inventory system is really "diabloish", although it has more than 100 bugs. Also, the thousand pounder is weaker than that skeleton king, which is really confusing. He doesn't have alot of spells either, maybe 3 or 4.
Bugs/Hive Description:N/A, the hive description is acceptable. Now all the bugs in the map really kill the fun, so i would suggest you fix the bugs first before you add something new.
Overall:15.5/20, well that's a high rating

. The map is overall alot of fun, but there isn't alot of "replay value". The things that kill the fun:
-Bugs
-The spells
-Bugs
-Difficulty
-Bugs
But when you have released v1.20, then it might actually be raised to 16 or 17/20. Good luck
15.5/20:
Perfect
Comment: "
...simply amazing..."