Citadel of Time: Scourge Invasion

[Moderator]

A few months later...
ap0: Rejected

19:03, 19th Apr 2010
ap0calypse: Rejected

Add a type, improve description.

 

[Zenonoth]

This map is really good ( At least in my opinion ) It deserves 4/5

 

[dexm]

pls fix the description pls pls but the map is desent 4/5

 

[knight26]

This map is really good ( At least in my opinion ) It deserves 4/5

I see you like to put ''in my opinion'' in every comment, lemme tell u something, if you post a comment, therefore we know/we can guess that that comment expresses your personal opinion, so u shouldn't rly put that everywhere..

On-topic:
gonna dl, and review tomorrow.

 

[Coffeeholic]

Things I Liked About the Map:

- Life indicator floating text
- Decent array of hero types
- Bosses were quite challenging
- Mountain King has Taunt -- tanks should always have this
- Holy light heals self

Things I Didn't Like:

- Heroes are pre-selected with no indication of which you're getting ahead of time
- First skill is pre-selected when other skills could be more useful at the beginning
- Some custom skills, like "Judgment", lacked a good description of what you're learning and then shows up with Chain Lightning's description once you learn it
- No cinematics
- No real quests
- No custom items
- Hardly any custom spells
- No triggered spells
- Heroes aren't very unique
- Too much hack 'n' slash
- Some Paladin creeps used an annoyingly long divine shield
- Creeps didn't get progressively stronger; they were just spammed more
- Creeps were too much based on regular Warcraft units
- There were about 20 Kel'Thuzad ghosts...
- Lack of story, even towards the end of the game when I expected at least SOMETHING explaining what was going on
- Lousy ending -- instant victory for killing a randomly unexplained Crypt Lord

I'm a fan of classic linear style Warcraft RPGs, but this one had nothing special to make it unique or interesting. Nothing was horribly bad or glitchy about it, but it was boring to say the least. I give it a 2/5.

 

[Pedagree]

thanks for the comments

And for coffeeholic:
I really appreciate you comment about what is good and bad, and in the following month i will try to change few things.
I'm also working on my own game so i don't have much time for this.

thanks anyway

 

[Ironside]

Information:
The Bad points outrun the Good Points, and your description breaks the rules.

As a Reviewer of the Map Reviewers Group, I joined the THW Cleaning Event.
I end up writing a fast review, or just posting the end state of the map, rating is not always included!


Current State for this map: Rejected


I will contact the moderator to Approve/Reject the map, depending on what you recieved.