Christmas skins - Approveable?

[X-OMG-X]

Yo.

I have made 3 christmas skins now. 1 of them is allready uploaded and is waiting for moderation. My 2 other skins isnt uploaded yet, i wanted some feedback before uploading. The first skin is my 'Christmas Rider' and the second skin is 'Santa's Wife'. What do you think about them? What is bad, and what is good? Is it approveable? I would like to hear what you mean. Constructive comments and advices is welcome.



Update 1.0

Updated the jaina skin. I have given it a candy stick and changed the color of the gem.

 

[pippo]

I think the center of the clothes is mostly simply, it needs more details (and mby more shadows?)...

 

[KalamMekhar]

did you try making the wife's staff a candy-cane? it might suite the theme better.

 

[Deleted member 157129]

It could actually work out pretty nicely on Jaina, if you put some more effort into it! Though I dislike the Thrall-santa a LOT. :\ His skin looks like.. coloured paper, and what the hell's with his green lips?

As I haven't seen this done before, I'll congratulate you on originality.

 

[X-OMG-X]

Thanks for the comments guys. The skins isnt fully done, because i personally think i can do it better. Anyways i will try to do as you guys said, and yea a candy stick would be cool, i had the same idea.

[EDIT] what do you guys think about the jaina skin now? and do you have any ideas for improvements on both the jaina skin, and the thrall skin?

 

[Deolrin]

There are literally NO shadings on those skins. Looks very plain.

 

[Kuhneghetz]

There are literally NO shadings on those skins. Looks very plain.

What debode said.

 

[Pharaoh_]

Plus, it looks like a candy girl, not santa's wife; at least remake the staff she's holding.