Moderator
M
Moderator
08:36, 9th Oct 2013
enjoy: Looks great, could be useful.
enjoy: Looks great, could be useful.
(6 ratings)
Aaaaw thats cute!![]()
Seems like you've been improving in your absence. Much better compared to the rest of your icons. Well done, you're improving. Whoop ;P
She has done much better work than this, but none the less, its still a great icon, that has been executed well.
Seems like you've been improving in your absence. Much better compared to the rest of your icons. Well done, you're improving. Whoop ;P
and i really, really dont know what is the point of this post.Really, really nice.
4/5.
and i really, really dont know what is the point of this post.
Um, he's praising & giving his opinion of a general rating for it, much like you and others have done?...HappyCockroack said:and i really, really dont know what is the point of this post.
Ah.I'm getting pretty sick of explaining this to people, 4/5 is not a bad rating, it's a good rating. I really like the icon and the only thing wrong with it is that its style doesn't quite fit right into the game.
Um, he's praising & giving his opinion of a general rating for it, much like you and others have done?...
Ah.
Yeah, 4/5 is 80/100; that's a B (above average), which is quite good in a lot of ways.
However, have you given any thought to slightly increasing your ratio, so as to allow more expressive ratings? i.e. Something as small as "X/10" gives you a lot more room in terms of grading things. Also, have you considered using decimal values (i.e. "4.5/5", or "1.3/5")?
Perhaps people just view what you're saying as more of a fact; they need to realize it's an opinion. : )
~~~
That being said, I love this icon; the artistry is vibrant, the wolf really looks alive. I'm a little off-put by the style; it's definitely in-keeping with your regular style, but as usual struggles a bit (IMO) in comparison with Blizzard icons; would need a lot more contrast and such. However, for non-in-game settings, this is great.
Ah, I didn't realize you were basing this off of the Hive's system (to be completely honest, I've never actually used it myself; tend to ignore Ratings altogether. Just kind of a popularity contest IMO). That being said, I still can't help but wonder if some modularity would help you out. : )Since Hive's rating system is out of 5, anything else would give people an inaccurate idea of what my rating is as they have to wonder whether I round up or down.