BTNShield

[Moderator]

09:34, 10th Aug 2009
zombie2279: It's blurry and undefined as hell, but it's a recolor anyway which is not approvable.

 

[Panda]

Please provide Work in Progress pictures or pictures of you editing this. Thanks.

 

[MultiGod]

Here ->http://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums/texturing-and-surfacing-274/third-icon-worth-submitting-139458/

 

[Panda]

Ok, thanks. Nice work. BTW, no changes too be seen.

 

[MultiGod]

Ok, thanks. Nice work. BTW, no changes too be seen.

What do you mean?

 

[Panda]

What i mean by that is that i see no changes to make.

 

[Latecat]

Agreed. Very well made.
5/5. With the WIPS it could be also a upgrade.

 

[TheHunterKiller]

Hmm, pretty nice. Useful for items or something.

 

[breebree123]

good work,but give it a shine of light or something
4/5

 

[supertoinkz]

me thinks its so simple
4/5

 

[MultiGod]

I think so too. But what can i do?
Removing the crosses and adding an emblem is hard because I don't know where to highlight and shade.
Thorns on the sides is harder.
Besides this is and edit of an icon simpler. Well, yeah I'm not professional.

 

[supertoinkz]

emblem?
easy, just think this
where would be the lights come from?
thats all

 

[Licheus]

I like it right now. Doesn't matter if it's simple as long as it looks good. At least to me

 

[Deolrin]

It's EXTREMELY blurry. Any reason for that?

 

[MultiGod]

I looked at it again but it ain't blur for me.

 

[Somnium]

Yeah it's kinda blurry, may I ask what resultion you drown it at ? Since that might be the reason of the blurryness. It might also be, becausr you put too much detail in it when it was at full scale.

As for the representing item, the X on it doesn't seem to be symetrical. The color choice seems monotone, and a ltile dull. Also we can't see the whole shield, which i think is a shame. It's missing some highlights aswell but i wouldn't worry about that too much. Also the cross and the X on thie shield both seem a litle unevan, a bit wavy. Not a bad icon thogugh

 

[Palaslayer]

not bad, but a little to blurry. also, make the shield differ from the background. and add some more highlights, since it is metallish?

and if the light comes from the top right of the shield, then there shouldnt be a highlight only at the right bottom of it...

 

[Squidle]

This is not really WarCraft-style.
And I don't really like the icon.

 

[Palaslayer]

http://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums/texturing-and-surfacing-274/which-icon-is-better-139500/

 

[MultiGod]

Argh bullshit bullshit the BTN is different!

Tried to reupload, rename, reborder and still the same.....

EDIT : Problemo Solved.

 

[Dmazzz]

It seems to me that 80% or more of this icons was made with filters, that would explain all the blurryness and overusing the same filter also explains the monotone coloring.

 

[Somnium]

Dmazz, personally i don't really see any filters used there. Maybe it's a problem with my eye sight ?

 

[Dmazzz]

It looks like he took the original shield icon, drew an X on it and filtered the whole inside.

 

[MultiGod]

Yeah you're right! I used FILTERS for 45% of it.