BTNMarine

[Moderator]

20:36, 10th Dec 2013
enjoy: The model needs fix, but the icon needs a complete makeover. I am setting it to awaiting update. The icon (as it looks now) is unacceptable.

 

[Avex]

You need to have the proper borders.

As much as I hate CnP, I guess the whole model-approved thing will work.

Plus its Blizzard Art..

 

[Roland]

I really disgust CnP Icons as well, but I really like Handmade icons.

 

[stonneash]

Sir I think this icon needs editing and probably a rework for the following reasons:
-No color variation; your only using "gold" as a color
-Lack of details; Due to the poor coloring and shading plus the undefined edges
-Incorrect Borders; You need to have original WCIII borders on your icon. use this tool next time.
-Incorrect Scale; it appears to be that you worked on this icon in a smaller size than 64X64 then scaled it up which caused all these pixels to be visible.

Due to all the reason above I rate this Icon as Poor and would ask you to make a proper remake.

 

[Arhowk]

Sir I think this icon needs editing and probably a rework for the following reasons:
-No color variation; your only using "gold" as a color
-Lack of details; Due to the poor coloring and shading plus the undefined edges
-Incorrect Borders; You need to have original WCIII borders on your icon. use this tool next time.
-Incorrect Scale; it appears to be that you worked on this icon in a smaller size than 64X64 then scaled it up which caused all these pixels to be visible.

Due to all the reason above I rate this Icon as Poor and would ask you to make a proper remake.

He didn't make it, its the marine icon from sc1 :O

 

[stonneash]

He didn't make it, its the marine icon from sc1 :O

I just don't want to put labels on him and his\the work, it might offense him somehow.

 

[Avex]

Who cares if it offends him? It breaks the rules and we should teach him them and guide him.

I hate "political correctness"

 

[Roland]

Who cares if it offends him? It breaks the rules and we should teach him them and guide him.

I hate "political correctness"

Dude, I really agree on you.

 

[ner016]

Sir I think this icon needs editing and probably a rework for the following reasons:
-No color variation; your only using "gold" as a color
-Lack of details; Due to the poor coloring and shading plus the undefined edges
-Incorrect Borders; You need to have original WCIII borders on your icon. use this tool next time.
-Incorrect Scale; it appears to be that you worked on this icon in a smaller size than 64X64 then scaled it up which caused all these pixels to be visible.

Due to all the reason above I rate this Icon as Poor and would ask you to make a proper remake.

It's Originally SC 1 Marine Icon

 

[Avex]

You still need to fix the borders if you even want a chance of approval

 

[enjoy]

CNP is not allowed, doesn't matter if you have a model. A screenshot icon is allowed of a model or skin that you own, but stealing is not. And if you do steal, you will be banned. Don't do it again.