BTNHopliteHelmetUPG3

[Moderator]

22:30, 25th Sep 2009
oh_snap: Rejected until updated.

 

[Panda]

Look quite good, may need more shading.

 

[Chief-Oblivion]

Yeah, the shading is kinda blah and the colors are pretty bold.

 

[Dentothor]

much neater/smaller brushes man. you look like you are using the same size brush throughout the whole icon making it look very simple. same as the others

 

[TheHunterKiller]

It looks pretty nice but yea, do what the others said. The glow looks a bit strange too.

 

[Cthulus]

As with the other Greek helmets you submitted, this one is of a mediocre, acceptable quality and has good but a bit scratchy shading. As another has pointed out, the background glow looks a bit off-putting, in my opinion, and the colors look somewhat low-quality at times.. Anyway, listen to what these guys have said and make some changes. But for now, 3/5 Useful

 

[PsychoNerdial]

This one is.... Not so good :/ Kinda messy for some reason.

 

[AbstractCreativity]

Yeah, I figured that out as well. This one is a bit messy when compared to the others.

And about the glow... I like weird glows ^^
EDIT: And btw, go look at the attachments to my post in the T1 thread. That's the in-game quality. The icons look far worse on the THW preview than in the actual game... Don't know what it is, but THW just screws the image quality up a bit.

 

[enjoy]

This goes for all three of your helmet icons.
More shading is needed! And blend out between the colours, so it will get a floating transition between a dark, and a light color.
Also blend the background out in the black in the edges.