BTNArthasLifeDrain

[Moderator]

20:10, 10th Oct 2014
Sin'dorei300: I think u have to put into practice the suggestions of the contest's Jury.
Also, i'd like to quote Hemske: "I love that you tried your hand on such different type of icons especially considering your level of skill. That's really brave of you and I admire that."

 

[youness]

Awesome.

 

[A Void]

Lack of detail, 3/5.

 

[Sunreaver]

Why not name it Frostmourne Hungers
Voting for approval

 

[Chen]

Why not name it Frostmourne Hungers
Voting for approval

Thanks! Name it the one you like, but you coyld still name it like the original or Soul Drain.

 

[GaLaxY_256]

Voting for Approval with 2/5 lacking or 3/5 useful with followings:

• Copy and paste

and see comments:

Comments

I suggest you to add some frost effect on blade. Since Frostmourne is frozen cursed sword, your icon is much feel like normal sword. As stated above it has copy from BTNImpalingBolt so it was went down to 2/5 but I'll give 3/5 :thumb_up:

 

[Chen]

Voting for Approval with 2/5 lacking or 3/5 useful with followings:

• Copy and paste

and see comments:

Comments

I suggest you to add some frost effect on blade. Since Frostmourne is frozen cursed sword, your icon is much feel like normal sword. As stated above it has copy from BTNImpalingBolt so it was went down to 2/5 but I'll give 3/5 :thumb_up:

It's not a CnP, But I'll do that. But here's a WIP to see it's not a CnP.

NOTEo not steal it and upload without mah permission, but you can if you will of course. And you can edit it but don't upload that edited version in other sites(how could I know).

 

[Vinz]

Da heck LS you know how hard it is to CnP Impaling Bolts? Trust me I tried. It sucked. o.o

OT: Outlines need more light.

 

[Chen]

Da heck LS you know how hard it is to CnP Impaling Bolts? Trust me I tried. It sucked. o.o

OT: Outlines need more light.

I havent even seen that inpaling bolt thing whats that

Kay. Ill try too

 

[Vinz]

The Ballista Bolt.

 

[Hemske]

I really like this one. You got something good going here. You should work on your values though, check it up if you don't know what it is. But you basically have the same values over the whole icon and it makes it look very dull. You got some very good ideas overall, just keep practicing

 

[Chen]

AThanks Hemske!

 

[GaLaxY_256]

This is DotA Windrunner's skill, powershot. Which is edited from original Ballista Bolt.
If you wanna see it just play RoC Warcraft

 

[Chen]

Okay, but still, this is not CnP.

 

[Vinz]

The blue runes on the middle do not match.

 

[A Void]

This is DotA Windrunner's skill, powershot. Which is edited from original Ballista Bolt.
If you wanna see it just play RoC Warcraft

You are incorrect, this icon is 100% freehand. I see nothing copy and pasted here, it also doesn't match the arrow you are pointing.

 

[Heinvers]

This is DotA Windrunner's skill, powershot. Which is edited from original Ballista Bolt.
If you wanna see it just play RoC Warcraft

What CnP? :O

You don't know what you're talking about LS.

 

[kakuzu]

Interesting , nice icon !

 

[Vinz]

A note, have a black line between the blade and the glow. Then use dodge tool on the glow (random areas) to make it stand out.

 

[Chen]

Not sure if I did this right but yeah, updated. I wonder if there's a way to set it back to pending somehow, though.

 

[PrinceYaser]

Not sure if I did this right but yeah, updated. I wonder if there's a way to set it back to pending somehow, though.

Man you can just contact the icon reviewers or staff.

Btw, the update looks cool!

 

[GaLaxY_256]

This seems better now

Also, I would like to apologize for saying that it's a CnP. I was a kid when I have seen this, now I see this is a good art from you
Vote for approval

 

[Chen]

I'm pretty sure that I was a kid when I uploaded this as well, based on my previous behavior. Thanks, though

@Maxwell is there any way for this to get another review or be set back to pending?

 

[Maxwell]

After changes was made it looks like really good sfx icon. As long as Sin'dorei are, sadly, inactive I Approve this Icon.

 

[LISBOAH]

I like this icon. Thanks!