Broken Isles

[Moderator]

Orcnet

18:54, 31th May 2013

Comment

Review

Map Approved

Broken Isles (No Version/s Stated) Rate Score Percent Letter 5/5 91-100 A Rate Score Percent Letter 4/5 81-90% B Rate Score Percent Letter 3/5 75-80% C Rate Score Percent Letter 2/5 70-74% D Rate Score Percent Letter 1/5 50-69% F Overview: Gameplay "Broken Isles" is a 1v1 melee map based on the sunken ruins theme. "A well decent game to be played for a 1v1, but there is some problems going on the expansion sites since the AI doesn't hire transport ships and go pass the seas how about make up a trigger for it but for now its not important as long as the game play is fixed with enough creep difficulty and space format, its fine." Terrain "Terrain is wonderful, the sunken ruins never seem to amazed me." Management "Overall a neat melee map to be played for a 1 on 1 match." Total Score: Rate Score Percent Letter 10/15 83% B

 

[Filmting]

the map seems very nice
there is only one thing making me to question
will the AI use the transports?, i think they dont, i would change the ship for the goblings zeppelings, they use the zeppelings, i dont like when the AI cant play in the same way as a human
or waygates

I will not balance any of my maps around AI. Makes them less fun.

 

[Filmting]

in melee maps, the AI play must be balanced, Fun or balance, always balance, get inside in a ship is almost the same thing as get inside in a zeppeling.

Argument invalid in this context. Map is designed for humans, not AI's. I do no make the AI, uses standard blizzard AI.

 

[Binsu]

Hello there, played your map and this is really well-done melee map. Here is my review btw:

[+] Good Points:
-Terrain is very great. You used fitting doodads and you fill them and used it at its fullest. Terrain is not flat also, nice job! Tho only to suggest is how about make tiles smooth and it will give a better result.
-Map has required resources:

• Gold Mine
• Goblin Merchant
• Fountain
• Shipyard

-Player were position very well
-Creeps are balanced enough

[-] Bad Points:
-None

[] Suggestions:
-Some minor terrain improements like making the tiles smooth.
-Maybe make an additional options to the melee AI script that lets them buy a ship and go through islands

Note: Suggestions were not meant to be always follow but better if yes.

Overall, this is a great melee map with great terrain, well positioned player locations, balanced creeps and enoug resources for a melee map. I woul rate this 5/5 and +4 REP to you!

Voting for Approval also!

 

[Binsu]

Thats was what i was saying, AI wont use ships.
They can use the zepelings or the waygates.
thats why you dont see shipyards in melee very offen.

Its only a suggestion so its ok for him to deny.

 

[WolfFarkas]

Its only a suggestion so its ok for him to deny.

I surrender

 

[Binsu]

^ What?

 

[CroMoX]

^ What?

He doesn't have friends so he wan'ts AI

 

[Orcnet]

map approved see details on top :>

 

[JCarrill0]

it's a short 1v1 game, I love the terrain (sunken ruins is not a big fav of mine though). What you did with the lighting, and the Terrain is simply beautiful! 5/5

 

[UrijelV]

Very nice map.

 

[AndresMachado]

Love this

 

[Filmting]

Love this

I don't understand why. You shouldn't It's actually quite terrible. Only the idea is kinda interresting, but I executed this one poorly. Also one of my earlier maps so eh.