BTNHeavensLightningStaff

[Moderator]

13:36, 14th Aug 2009
zombie2279: The wips look fake. Give me a .psd or .xcf file, I won't accept anything else. There's a huuuuge difference between the final and the second wip.

08:39, 17th Aug 2009
zombie2279: No proper evidence shown. Notify me if it's otherwise.

9:04, 21st Aug 2009
zombie2279: Some more contrast to distinguish the staff from the background would be welcome, and some more visible details to the middle, since the background is now more in perspective than the staff itself. Once you're done, add more shading. Use black outlines instead of white when doing icons.

29th Aug
zombie2279: Improper direction of changes made, advise observation of other icons to achieve a better result. The messyness of the middle has to go.

 

[olyvian]

fullview
with wips
and .psd

 

[TheHunterKiller]

Looks really awesome. Wips?

 

[olyvian]

Check the first post ^^

 

[HappyCockroach]

I sense tracing-over...

 

[olyvian]

I sense tracing-over...

huh? xD

 

[X-OMG-X]

this staff is really great!
5/5

 

[Mobilize]

I sense tracing-over...

Yeah, what a strange feeling, I got it too...

 

[olyvian]

Yeah, what a strange feeling, I got it too...

:O what does it means?

 

[HappyCockroach]

tracing-over? To trace over, obviously.

Whether CnP or not, it looks bad.

 

[olyvian]

tracing-over? To trace over, obviously.

Whether CnP or not, it looks bad.

Oh sry , im a little noob at this x). Check the first post.

 

[Somnium]

Awesome, could you mayde supply us with a full size picture ? It will show that you obviously were a good boy and didn't C'n'P

Edit: Never mind I seen first post, I think you didn't copy this but ill be watching you! xD
Anyways as for the icon itself, the staff is a little crowded it looks good at high resolution but when made into an icon, not so much

 

[Licheus]

I think it looks just fine. Good painting, wips added... 5/5.

 

[The Panda]

Hard to see, No good color contrast, Effects blend with the staff too much.

 

[Godslayer]

yeah panda is right, bit more shape to the staff wouldnt hurt,
anyway it looks nice

 

[Zombie]

The wips look fake. Give me a .psd or .xcf file, I won't accept anything else. There's a huuuuge difference between the final and the second wip.

 

[PsychoNerdial]

I <3 it

 

[Darkgamma]

Hard to see, No good color contrast. Effects blend with the staff too much.

Yeah, blurry. Change the bg color a tad bit, maybe reddish or HOLY

Get the point?

 

[olyvian]

Yeah, blurry. Change the bg color a tad bit, maybe reddish or HOLY

Get the point?

updated

 

[HELL_YA]

This looks awsome the high resolution is hardcore
I rate this a 5/5

 

[Darkgamma]

Nice, I now approve.