Wow fast review,
And don't worry I'm not offended.
It was an idea that I had and made in a day. (Mainly so that I could play it with friends)
And then I uploaded it here, (why not?)
-First point: I would like to make a new terrain at some point yes, but I decided that this would be one of the better melee maps. My reasons are that it accomidates a reasonable number of players, there is more than just 1 gold mine per person, AND there are plenty of places for people to nibble a trees to make a suprise attack!
-Second point: That is a fair point, I'm not sure what to do with that then, hurm.
-Third&Fourth points: If they relate back to your second point then I kind of get you, otherwise, I don't really get you.