BTNstarcraft2repair

Moderator · Jul 11, 2009

09:39, 12th Jul 2009
zombie2279: Simple and blurry as hell. Add more details to the wrench, make them look more realistic and add shading and highlights. Reference real pictures if that makes your task easier.

Rejected until updated.

The Panda · Jul 11, 2009

Review,
---------------------------------------------
1:Good quality.
2:Quite simple as of the one color, but may come in handy.
3:Maybe make it smaller and put it in the middle so you can see the whole icon.
---------------------------------------------
(All my recommendations to your icon, you can use these or not your choice)
Army-of-pandas

joel79 · Jul 11, 2009

Army-of-Pandas said:
Review,
---------------------------------------------
1:Good quality.
2:Quite simple as of the one color, but may come in handy.
3:Maybe make it smaller and put it in the middle so you can see the whole icon.
---------------------------------------------
(All my recommendations to your icon, you can use these or not your choice)
Army-of-pandas

Thanks army, i'll fix it up very soon, nice to have a good review from a veterain like you :grin:

X.e.r.e.X · Jul 11, 2009

Meh... It's just too plain and simple
At least give it ATC borders if you want it to be used as repair.

joel79 · Jul 11, 2009

X.e.r.e.X said:
Meh... It's just too plain and simple
At least give it ATC borders if you want it to be used as repair.

One, it's a theme, if i made it more flashy and all, it wouldn't be the starcraft 2 repair button anymore lol

I added an ATC for some reason that didn't even cross my mind XD

X.e.r.e.X · Jul 11, 2009

joel79 said:
One, it's a theme, if i made it more flashy and all, it wouldn't be the starcraft 2 repair button anymore lol

How about you just improvise and make it "flashy" instead of just making it plain and call it SC 2 repair button.

The Panda · Jul 11, 2009

Army-of-Pandas said:
Review,
---------------------------------------------
1:Good quality.(NONE)
2:Quite simple as of the one color, but may come in handy.(DONE)
3:Maybe make it smaller and put it in the middle so you can see the whole icon.(DONE)
---------------------------------------------
(All my recommendations to your icon, you can use these or not your choice)
Army-of-pandas

Looks nice now man, and no problem.

joel79 · Jul 11, 2009

X.e.r.e.X said:
How about you just improvise and make it "flashy" instead of just making it plain and call it SC 2 repair button.

Because.... I want it to look like the actual real life star craft 2 repair icon... lol

breebree123 · Jul 12, 2009

too glowy, very blurry. .
its shading is good. .
has a nice quality. .
4/5

Avex · Jul 12, 2009

I like it, reminds me of the good old days. Do attack, Stop, Patrol and all the old spells too (Stim pack etc)

joel79 · Jul 12, 2009

IamtheRper said:
I like it, reminds me of the good old days. Do attack, Stop, Patrol and all the old spells too (Stim pack etc)

haha i'm planning to just gotta define the lines better on the computer cause i stretched it and it's a bit blurry.

Avex · Jul 13, 2009

I wish we could recolor the ATC borders, the yellow looks just, horrid.

joel79 · Jul 13, 2009

IamtheRper said:
I wish we could recolor the ATC borders, the yellow looks just, horrid.

I agree haha but regulation is regulation god forbid a variation or some creativity

BTNstarcraft2repair

BTNstarcraft2repair (Icon)

Moderator

Moderator

Similar threads