BTNMarine

Moderator · Nov 27, 2013

20:36, 10th Dec 2013
enjoy: The model needs fix, but the icon needs a complete makeover. I am setting it to awaiting update. The icon (as it looks now) is unacceptable.

Avex · Nov 27, 2013

You need to have the proper borders.

As much as I hate CnP, I guess the whole model-approved thing will work.

Plus its Blizzard Art..

Roland · Nov 27, 2013

I really disgust CnP Icons as well, but I really like Handmade icons.

stonneash · Nov 27, 2013

Sir I think this icon needs editing and probably a rework for the following reasons:
-No color variation; your only using "gold" as a color
-Lack of details; Due to the poor coloring and shading plus the undefined edges
-Incorrect Borders; You need to have original WCIII borders on your icon. use this tool next time.
-Incorrect Scale; it appears to be that you worked on this icon in a smaller size than 64X64 then scaled it up which caused all these pixels to be visible.

Due to all the reason above I rate this Icon as Poor and would ask you to make a proper remake.

Arhowk · Nov 27, 2013

stonneash said:
Sir I think this icon needs editing and probably a rework for the following reasons:
-No color variation; your only using "gold" as a color
-Lack of details; Due to the poor coloring and shading plus the undefined edges
-Incorrect Borders; You need to have original WCIII borders on your icon. use this tool next time.
-Incorrect Scale; it appears to be that you worked on this icon in a smaller size than 64X64 then scaled it up which caused all these pixels to be visible.

Due to all the reason above I rate this Icon as Poor and would ask you to make a proper remake.

He didn't make it, its the marine icon from sc1 :O

stonneash · Nov 28, 2013

Arhowk said:
He didn't make it, its the marine icon from sc1 :O

I just don't want to put labels on him and his\the work, it might offense him somehow.

Avex · Nov 28, 2013

Who cares if it offends him? It breaks the rules and we should teach him them and guide him.

I hate "political correctness"

Roland · Nov 28, 2013

IamtheRper said:
Who cares if it offends him? It breaks the rules and we should teach him them and guide him.

I hate "political correctness"

Dude, I really agree on you.

ner016 · Nov 29, 2013

stonneash said:
Sir I think this icon needs editing and probably a rework for the following reasons:
-No color variation; your only using "gold" as a color
-Lack of details; Due to the poor coloring and shading plus the undefined edges
-Incorrect Borders; You need to have original WCIII borders on your icon. use this tool next time.
-Incorrect Scale; it appears to be that you worked on this icon in a smaller size than 64X64 then scaled it up which caused all these pixels to be visible.

Due to all the reason above I rate this Icon as Poor and would ask you to make a proper remake.

It's Originally SC 1 Marine Icon

Avex · Dec 6, 2013

You still need to fix the borders if you even want a chance of approval

enjoy · Dec 10, 2013

CNP is not allowed, doesn't matter if you have a model. A screenshot icon is allowed of a model or skin that you own, but stealing is not. And if you do steal, you will be banned. Don't do it again.

BTNMarine

BTNMarine (Icon)

SC1 Marine V2

Moderator

Moderator

Avex

Avex

Resources

Roland

Roland

stonneash

stonneash

Resources

Arhowk

Arhowk

stonneash

stonneash

Resources

Avex

Avex

Resources

Roland

Roland

ner016

ner016

Resources

Avex

Avex

Resources

enjoy

enjoy

Resources

Similar threads