Who Will Win?: Starcraft vs Warcraft

[WOWWARS]

Who Will Win? Starcraft Franchise or Warcraft Franchise.

Note: NO FLAMING

its works like this:

SC: Shoots* Arthas WC: Frost Shock!

finished

 

[Snarewave]

SC: Shoots* Arthas WC: Frost Shock!

Nerd Fight!

 

[Deleted member 157129]

Uhh.. what?

 

[Darkness-4ever]

Starcraft.
Why?
NUKES!

 

[WherewolfTherewolf]

Does Starcraft have Dragons in it? No? Then Warcraft will always be > then Starcraft

 

[Darkness-4ever]

I'd pick a Battlecruiser over a dragon any day of the week.

 

[Oohforf]

Well, since I am not really into futuristic games, warcraft.

 

[kevin1gamer]

StarCraft obviously

 

[Teh_Ephy]

This is like that Zerg v Tyranid thread a while back. Starcraft would win because they have numbers.

 

[kevin1gamer]

Warcraft = 2000 BC
StarCraft = 4000 AD


Think about it.

 

[Teh_Ephy]

Not so much.
Warcraft = armies with magic
Starcraft = huge armies with technology

 

[Coolty44]

Warcraft wins becuase we are a warcraft 3 modding community.

 

[YourNameHere]

Warcraft wins becuase we are a warcraft 3 modding community.

This, we can just add some awesome hordes of Starcraft units aswell.

 

[ronojales]

i am seeing more and more Starcraft units in Warcraft. they are invading us slowly.

 

[XXXElectroXXX]

i am seeing more and more Starcraft units in Warcraft. they are invading us slowly.

Ok, Warcraft fans, prepare your swords, we must defend Warcraft at all cost!
/offtopic
I really think Warcraft, cuz, we have to say, story is 10000000000010010101 times better.

 

[Cpt.ZnacK]

Naw WARCRAFT 3 Pawns Starcraft why? warcraft 1,warcraft 2,warcraft 3 ,warcraft 3 Frozen Throne and World of "Warcraft".... and starcraft 1 and soon to be released starcraft 2...MMmmm hard to choose....especially since warcraft 3 has Alot more Maps(Games one can say) and could go on....so i will... WC3 = human,orc,demon,nighteld,bloodelf,undead and and and....starcraft = terran,protoss and Zerg.... Technology can only do that much...magic can do anything....example 50 mil tanks....one spell to rust them all...lol

 

[Tleno]

Starcraft 2 will just crush Warcraft with it's polygons and modding capabilities.
And it has nukes.

 

[Herian]

Warcraft III will crush Starcraft 2 EASILY.
Reason: all splash spells, and dragons, orcs, undead! KICK TANKS! (though zergs are cool >.>)

 

[mr-mushy]

Starcraft for sure. Nukes. Enough said.

 

[haxel96]

Warcraft III will PWN starcraft
I'll just make a custom spell that kill all starcraft units...

 

[WherewolfTherewolf]

Starcraft 2 = Commercialized mapping, little drive to make something good (SOCIALISM)
Warcraft 3 = Free mapping, no incentive thus drive to make something good for the point of making something good (ANARCHY)

 

[Elenai]

I cite General Frank's space orcs: Warcraft wins.

 

[NhazUl]

>.> Eh... Well, if the Swarm attacks the Warcraft universe, the Scourge will just kill-reanimate-kill-reanimate the Zerg... who wins? Hm... The undead zerg under Bolvar Fordragon, I guess. >.>

 

[LordDz]

Warcraft wins hands down.
What can battlecruisers and Scourge do when Warcraft brings fourth their Titans and Gods?

 

[NhazUl]

Eh, bring forth an undead infested Xel'Naga force?

 

[Arowanna]

Two names:
Sargeras and Pantheon

They form worlds... Really, does Starcraft have anything like that?
Of course, they can destory planest, but not make 'em, huge difference.

Update
To be honest... With all the lore of Warcraft, Starcraft won't stand a chanse

 

[Pharaoh_]

Starcraft for its editor features and Warcraft III for the lore.
P.S. Magic beats anything. Just try on your Divine Shield and pity, they are all dead helpless, without even attacking. Just bring some necromancers and again pity, you instantly double-size your Warcraft 3 army :/

Ok, is it time a wc3 vs. sc2 map to be made?

 

[Arowanna]

Starcraft for its editor features and Warcraft III for the lore.
P.S. Magic beats anything. Just try on your Divine Shield and pity, they are all dead helpless, without even attacking. Just bring some necromancers and again pity, you instantly double-size your Warcraft 3 army :/

Ok, is it time a wc3 vs. sc2 map to be made?

Would be cool to be honest

 

[Malcous]

To be honest... With all the lore of Warcraft, Starcraft won't stand a chanse

Agreed. Warcraft > Starcraft

 

[Azeroc]

SC2 is better.

Warcraft III will crush Starcraft 2 EASILY.
Reason: all splash spells, and dragons, orcs, undead! KICK TANKS! (though zergs are cool >.>)

Dragons, orcs and undead could be easily imported in SC2 map. Spells... you think SC2 won't have spells? -.-

Wc3 right now is fucked up.
1. Updates are very slow and 1.24 fucked up quite much maps
2. Many evil disadvantages in Wc3 WE, while SC2 WE doesn't have them.

SC2 right now is better than Wc3. Excuse as "no dragons in sc = it sux then" are fail - you can easily import dragon models in SC2 world editor x_x


Also don't forget! When SC2 will be finished it's creators will start developing Wc4 - at least that's what I heard.

 

[Pharaoh_]

Importing is an easy action in WC3 too, you know

 

[Azeroc]

Yes. Then why say that if SC2 has no dragons (or anything) it should suck then... :/

 

[Tleno]

Well, you can allways gene-engineer new dragon and orc or whatever creatures using Xel-naga technology that Protoss have and you can allways just absorb all those fantasy freak and turn them into part of your hivemind if you're zerg. Plus, Terran and Protoss have advanced technologies that can warp time/space or do anything else. Miracles do happen when you have a Yamato cannon, you know.
And, besides, everyone knows that Taurens will join Terran, from which terran will learn magic, Draenei will join Protoss becauce they have lots in common and becauce Bllizard want to keep their games balanced and zergs can absorb any organism.
So, Sci-fi pwns Fantasy.

 

[Fussiler1]

True. Also, it's laughable that the Titans would come to repel the invaders. They didn't do it with the Burning Legion, so why now?

 

[ACdestinydream]

starcraft>warcraft. nuff said.

 

[WherewolfTherewolf]

Well, you can allways gene-engineer new dragon and orc or whatever creatures using Xel-naga technology that Protoss have and you can allways just absorb all those fantasy freak and turn them into part of your hivemind if you're zerg. Plus, Terran and Protoss have advanced technologies that can warp time/space or do anything else. Miracles do happen when you have a Yamato cannon, you know.
And, besides, everyone knows that Taurens will join Terran, from which terran will learn magic, Draenei will join Protoss becauce they have lots in common and becauce Bllizard want to keep their games balanced and zergs can absorb any organism.
So, Sci-fi pwns Fantasy.

Genetically engineered Dragons just aren't the same....

And though miracles do happen when you have a Yamato canon, magic is the exact definition of miracles. Basically while the Sc2 guys have to stick in their reality when it comes to weapons, with the addition of magic in Wc you basically don't have to listen to the rules of reality.

Also Technology is expensive, Magic is free.

 

[Tleno]

Well, you can allways use some time-space quantumm physics sci-fi thingy that allows you to do some kinda like scientific magic.

 

[WherewolfTherewolf]

Yes but you have to add Time-Space quantumn physics sci-fi as a prefix for it to make sense and thus work in the game.

All you need to explain magic is to just say it's Magic

 

[Fussiler1]

Problem is, it's really hard to cast extremely strong magic that can destroy armies for example.

 

[WherewolfTherewolf]

And it drains all your ship's auxiliary power and then cuts into the electricity needed to maintain it's shields to fire a huge cannon

 

[tonyrydland]

Hei is it that hard do belive that Warcraft 3 is better than StarCraft 2. Even just listen to the title og the game. "War" craft... Yeah warcraft got the war in it. Now over to "Star" craft... Star? Oh yeah technologies from other planets and such. Now to the POINT: Warcraft 3 got the Holy Shield, and with that spell NO-ONE can attack it, just with that spell WC3 owns, even a STUP SLOW NUKE from SC2 can do anything, the nuke would then be similar to a attacking PEON! So WC3 owns SC2 with ONE DANM SPELL! ;D

 

[Arowanna]

@tleno - Sci-Fi owns Fantasy you say?
Well, basically, they are the same thing in different times...
So I've to say it's really weird how any of them can be "better"
than the other...
You can turn Warcraft into Sci-Fi and vice versa for Starcraft (would be awesome to see the development of the Protoss!)
So... I've to disagree.

But if we turn both in to Sci-Fi, Warcraft wins thanks to the magic
Think about it, a simple Marine with magic abilitys would crush for real!

 

[Elenai]

The Dreanei are basically magical protoss anyway...

 

[Darkness-4ever]

Clearly the bias is in favor of Warcraft as this is a Warcraft modding site, but the tables shall turn once SC2 comes out, you shall all see and bow before its awesomeness, enjoy your advantage while it lasts.

 

[WherewolfTherewolf]

I'm not sure If I'm going to play Sc2, it seems very commercialized. You realize all the good maps are going to cost money

 

[Fussiler1]

I'm not sure If I'm going to play Sc2, it seems very commercialized. You realize all the good maps are going to cost money

I thought that it only costed money to edit them?

 

[Darkness-4ever]

I thought that it only costed money to edit them?

It costs money to be in the presence of a map, to say a maps name, to address a map in any way, ye must bow to the whims of the map in SC2...
And I don't know if thats true or not... if it is link it so I may bug Blizzard with complaints.

 

[Tleno]

I'm not sure If I'm going to play Sc2, it seems very commercialized. You realize all the good maps are going to cost money

Well, I'm sure Bllizard is still holding-up the game becauce it can't decide to do it or not... Besides, acording to Starcraft April fools joke, Taurens joined terran. So, acording to my new theory, all of Warcraft races would join one of SC races that mostly fits them. Starcarft is whole universe, WC is just a Azeroth + Outland.

 

[ronojales]

*NUCLEAR LAUNCH DETECTED*

Arthas: Where the *#%@ is that Shadow Hunter?!? Big Bad Voodoo here now!
*Big Bad Voodoos*
*Booom!*
*Shadow Hunter dies, not everyone*

PEASANT: Waah a whole bunch of em zerglings and marines and zealots!
LICH KING: Release the dragons!!

---

 

[Phoonix]

this is a stupid question. there are no winners in this fight. both games have a huge fanbase, starcraft is more modable but then again in my experience making it too easy for people makes the modding less fun. you barely have any challenge, as in warcraft the modding is also nice and a bit harder thus giving people a chalange. it's just the same whit alot of game, they never die realy there are always times a game gets popular again. therefor this question is futile, there just is NO answer.