Village Defend v0.3

[Moderator]

21:57, 20th May 2014
Orcnet: needs more work.

 

[eubz]

The map has been optimized. Please, tell that also in your author's notes. It is one of the Map Submission Rules.

Protected/Open Source? Let the community know in the Hive description.

 

[Shadow Fury]

Pretty boring map with nothing really original in it. Here are some reasons for this:-

- Apart from some grammar mistakes, I don't find this map interesting because once your sniperman has become strong enough and you have researched the two researches, I just kept watching the sniperman killing zombies without doing anything
- The map size is really tiny and I didn't appreciate that
- No enemy variation. What does that mean? It means that there are only two types of zombies, Zombie and Boomer. What about any other type of zombie having some abilities to make the game more interesting and harder? Currently, the game is far too easy and boring
- After a certain wave (I don't remember which exactly), Boomers did not spawn anymore and they were the only hard ones to kill so the game became even more boring

SUGGESTIONS:-
- Well, the first thing I'd suggest is increasing the size of the map from Scenario ---> Map Size and Camera Bounds
- Then, add some new types of zombies by using models like Dalaran Reject or Dalaran Mutant and add to them some particular things like higher armor, HP or movement speed. Or you might add to them abilities like splitting into two smaller zombies when killed. That would be cooler
- Some abilities to the sniperman would be cool too like a bullet which explodes on contact and deals damage in a small area or an ability in which he launches a grenade
- Check that bug in which Boomers do not spawn (unluckily I can't open the map in the world editor for some unknown reasons so I can't tell you what's the problem)

OVERALL RESULT:-
A dull and boring map. I'm sorry but this map can't get more than 1/5 from me. Consider posting your map here

 

[jhonleus]

Thanks for your suggestion sir.! i fix my map now.

 

[PlankingWolf]

Pretty boring map with nothing really original in it. Here are some reasons for this:-

- Apart from some grammar mistakes, I don't find this map interesting because once your sniperman has become strong enough and you have researched the two researches, I just kept watching the sniperman killing zombies without doing anything
- The map size is really tiny and I didn't appreciate that
- No enemy variation. What does that mean? It means that there are only two types of zombies, Zombie and Boomer. What about any other type of zombie having some abilities to make the game more interesting and harder? Currently, the game is far too easy and boring
- After a certain wave (I don't remember which exactly), Boomers did not spawn anymore and they were the only hard ones to kill so the game became even more boring

SUGGESTIONS:-
- Well, the first thing I'd suggest is increasing the size of the map from Scenario ---> Map Size and Camera Bounds
- Then, add some new types of zombies by using models like Dalaran Reject or Dalaran Mutant and add to them some particular things like higher armor, HP or movement speed. Or you might add to them abilities like splitting into two smaller zombies when killed. That would be cooler
- Some abilities to the sniperman would be cool too like a bullet which explodes on contact and deals damage in a small area or an ability in which he launches a grenade
- Check that bug in which Boomers do not spawn (unluckily I can't open the map in the world editor for some unknown reasons so I can't tell you what's the problem)

OVERALL RESULT:-
A dull and boring map. I'm sorry but this map can't get more than 1/5 from me. Consider posting your map here

Really? A small map? I beg to differ. It is small, but it's appropriate enough for a simple map like his.

 

[Shadow Fury]

Really? A small map? I beg to differ. It is small, but it's appropriate enough for a simple map like his.

Still, I've never seen a map of size 32x32 of success. If the map is done at a larger scale, it's going to be much better.

 

[jhonleus]

i updated my map now. try to play it again! i hope u enjoy. if you have any suggestion again to my map just comment here.

 

[Razer!X]

Not the best map there is but has very good potential.

 

[Streak]

Pretty boring map with nothing really original in it. Here are some reasons for this:-

- Apart from some grammar mistakes, I don't find this map interesting because once your sniperman has become strong enough and you have researched the two researches, I just kept watching the sniperman killing zombies without doing anything
- The map size is really tiny and I didn't appreciate that
- No enemy variation. What does that mean? It means that there are only two types of zombies, Zombie and Boomer. What about any other type of zombie having some abilities to make the game more interesting and harder? Currently, the game is far too easy and boring
- After a certain wave (I don't remember which exactly), Boomers did not spawn anymore and they were the only hard ones to kill so the game became even more boring

SUGGESTIONS:-
- Well, the first thing I'd suggest is increasing the size of the map from Scenario ---> Map Size and Camera Bounds
- Then, add some new types of zombies by using models like Dalaran Reject or Dalaran Mutant and add to them some particular things like higher armor, HP or movement speed. Or you might add to them abilities like splitting into two smaller zombies when killed. That would be cooler
- Some abilities to the sniperman would be cool too like a bullet which explodes on contact and deals damage in a small area or an ability in which he launches a grenade
- Check that bug in which Boomers do not spawn (unluckily I can't open the map in the world editor for some unknown reasons so I can't tell you what's the problem)

OVERALL RESULT:-
A dull and boring map. I'm sorry but this map can't get more than 1/5 from me. Consider posting your map here

Nah who needs a better map when you can create just a simple one and also hard map? this map is easy i tell you that one but this map is easy go find your self a hardcore mAp if you dont want easy maps.
BTW nice review shadow fury(im not lying) and also shadow fury i see your point here on your first review of the map do you going to review it again? he said he updated it.

 

[LordDz]

What.

 

[Orcnet]

Your incoming works are impressive, but somehow this map leads down under, its very simple--too simple, since the map is just small and game play is on a small scale it should be atleast stated as a mini-game/defense typo.

The hero I'm using has an average attack animation and damage, which taking on expert level to be pointless, I'd suggest if the game would have difficulties, you might as well give your back into it by least giving some items, traps, you know tactics to keep lives.

Oh am I thinking about adding towers? that's a show.

For now it needs aesthetics, since its a single player map and all, not Death Sheep v9000.

 

[jhonleus]

yeah i know.. my map is just simple to play. but i make this map for fun. i put a lot effort and hardwork to make this simple map!

Your incoming works are impressive, but somehow this map leads down under, its very simple--too simple, since the map is just small and game play is on a small scale it should be atleast stated as a mini-game/defense typo.

 

[Shadow Fury]

Nah who needs a better map when you can create just a simple one and also hard map? this map is easy i tell you that one but this map is easy go find your self a hardcore mAp if you dont want easy maps.
BTW nice review shadow fury(im not lying) and also shadow fury i see your point here on your first review of the map do you going to review it again? he said he updated it.

Sadly, it is no more available :/
And my aim is not to make a "hardcore" map as you called it but at least try to improve the map a bit. I know that a map of that size can't become hardcore but at least acceptable enough for approval.