Tree Tag Tremble v2.8

[Moderator]

20:56, 3rd Jan 2013
Orcnet: hello this is a good map and all, but if you have read the rules carefully, maps that are now very common, via DotA, Warchasers, LoaP, Tree Tag, Element TD and others remakes are not allowed although the map is promising but we should all follow the rules:

Originality
Resources should be unique. Largely similar resources, such as icons or skins that are hue-adjusted version of each other, simple reskins that don't change the shape of the model, or maps that are effectively clones of each other, such as most LOAP and Footman Wars maps, may be rejected.

good day then

 

[Forsaken]

very good 5/5 + rep :D

 

[1rfan]

One of the best tree tag maps that i've played, 5/5

 

[sonofjay]

Information sounds very intriguing. One thing though, you should at least somehow tried to make a terrain that fit those sexy golems.

When playing tree tag, I always played as ent and almost mastered some clever techniques. But seeing the golems here, might try it for a change. Will try to come up a nice feedback when I finish a game or two with some friends.

 

[Orcnet]

hello this is a good map and all, but if you have read the rules carefully, maps that are now very common, via DotA, Warchasers, LoaP, Tree Tag, Element TD and others remakes are not allowed although the map is promising but we should all follow the rules:

Originality
Resources should be unique. Largely similar resources, such as icons or skins that are hue-adjusted version of each other, simple reskins that don't change the shape of the model, or maps that are effectively clones of each other, such as most LOAP and Footman Wars maps, may be rejected.

good day then

 

[UgoUgo]

Originality
Resources should be unique. Largely similar resources, such as icons or skins that are hue-adjusted version of each other, simple reskins that don't change the shape of the model, or maps that are effectively clones of each other, such as most LOAP and Footman Wars maps, may be rejected

From you

although the map is promising but we should all follow the rules:

How can you judge on the originality of when you just checked the map from this presentation...?

The word "may be" is different from "will be"....
The fact you roughly reviewed this map kinda make me pissed. We have spent years trying to find the right polishment and custom features and that's the reply we get? Its like asking every players to play the normal ashenvale treetag.

Yes, maps like these takes a lot of time to be reviewed, and we would understand if the moderation is delayed. But re-posting that rule is just... hurting.

You have once told me sonofjay's comment can be counted on, then why not count on his comment this time? Me as a Tree Tag fan will always be trying to keep the game Tree Tag from extinct by adding more new features to attract others. Do you seriously want us to keep on playing the same old Tree Tag that only had 3 infernal and one of them being utterly useless?

Then, why dont the mods just reject all resources that are similar? For example, why not reject all the explosion models and only leave 1 in this site? You guys cant accept variations right. Why not just remove all the 100+ additional swords icons in the Hive? They are all variations!

Me as one of the earlier creators of this map and a fan of this type of map is truly upset by how you judged without giving a valid pointers about the map's gameplay that could lead to its rejection. Sure, it has flaws but I guess thats what update for...

Neg-rep me, or rage at me if you find that Im being rude and inconsiderate to your reply. But Im pretty sure that I have being tolerant to your condition. Sure, you have life, I understand. We can wait for the moderation. But please, we are waiting for real reviews that can help us to improve the flaws of this map.

That is all.

 

[sonofjay]

Wow, this is a terrible way of rejecting a map.

But anyway, here is a tip UgoUgo, remake the terrain and make it at least decent or eye pleasing. If you did that then that is one step closer for this to be approve, actually try to make more gameplay mechanics that is unique to other Tree Tag map. You can also alter some other core gameplay while not really hurting the original concept of the map. (Which is for infernal to tag the ent)

Eye pleasing terrain + Unique gameplay features (A good example is having a physic system which is haven't seen for tree tag as far as i'm concern) = profit.

Here is some other tips:

About the buildings. Why don't you remake it from scratch? I mean remove all the old buildings then start brainstorming for unique concepts.

Camping on tree tag is kinda boring this days. Building a large base with towers towers wait for the timer to expire = profit. Well you might ask me this:

Q: How can I force players not to camp much?
A: Answer lies on my suggestion about the buildings.

 

[I3lackDeath]

The fact you roughly reviewed this map kinda make me pissed.

Don't get so worked up over stuff like this, there's absolutely no reason to.

You appealed the moderation, and we (that means the respective staff members and the uploader / the respective team) will work this out.

So, regarding this submission thread, get back to feedback.
The discussion of the apparent issue is held in SC where it belongs.

 

[UgoUgo]

Okay, I will calm myself.

@sonofjay : Thanks for the review even though Im not the one in charge currently. Terrains, yes it needs to be improved but I have no idea. We dont want to change the trees area as it decides the game winner most of the time. Any ideas without modiying the trees placement?

But about the building large base with towers, if you played this version long enough you will understand it is quite foolish to build a highly fortified base as it could be destroyed in matter of seconds without nearing the base. But sure, might come up with few buildings idea.

Also, what do you mean by physic system?

 

[sonofjay]

About the terrain, I think you guys can still remake the terrain without modifying the tree placement, just adding some decorations on some empty places will do good.

But the magic that can instant approve this is totally remaking the terrain from scratch, I know it will be hard to you guys if you don't have experience on terraining. But keep practicing and someday the practice will serve you guys big time.

About the camping, hmm yeah I guess this new types of tree tag doesn't allow camping anymore.

Physic system, there is a lot of way to describe this one and might be a little hard if no one knows about jass or vjass on your team.

So I think your options right now is to:

-Remake the terrain
-Remake the building concepts from scratch

EDIT:

Its kinda late but, don't be angry to Orcnet, he is a nice and cool guy.