To The Slaughter!(NEW)

[Moderator]

Orcnet

09:34, 10th June 2013

Comment

Review

Map Approved

To The Slaughter (No Version/s Stated) Rate Score Percent Letter 5/5 91-100 A Rate Score Percent Letter 4/5 81-90% B Rate Score Percent Letter 3/5 75-80% C Rate Score Percent Letter 2/5 70-74% D Rate Score Percent Letter 1/5 50-69% F Overview: Gameplay "To The Slaughter" is a 4v4 Melee map based on the Sunken Ruins theme. "Everything went smoothly now unlike the older releases, the creep difficulty became stable but you should fix the main base creep camps they look far away on what there defending, another is the change you did for the way gates, replacing it for an expansion site is very useful since your using boats for that and zeppelins." Terrain "Terrain has improved and became a wonderful site to see, but the ruined night elven buildings made it look like a distortion, either remove it or add some environment decor look." Management "In my Total, the map went smooth and its now useful for another melee map batch." Total Score: Rate Score Percent Letter 12/15 90% B

 

[Lichkings slave]

Screenshots :

 

[David]

Heres my review:

Good:

Simple and good terrain keeping wc3 style.
Places were well balanced.
Good placement of creeps and shops.

Bad:

I found nothing bad so far.

My vote: 3/5 Vote for aproval.

My comment: I think this deserves a 3/5 for the type of map it is.

 

[Lichkings slave]

Heres my review:

Good:

Simple and good terrain keeping wc3 style.
Places were well balanced.
Good placement of creeps and shops.

Bad:

I found nothing bad so far.

My vote: 3/5 Vote for aproval.

My comment: I think this deserves a 3/5 for the type of map it is.

Thank you

 

[Lichkings slave]

now this one is much beautifull that the first one
i liked the waterfalls
8000 doodas, thats mean well decorated
your game play now is more complete, the first one has a lot of emty space remember that?

the drops are a little unorthodox, if i can say, i mean lot an ankh of resurrection is not usual in melee. and no creeps loting books thats makes sad my hero. (XD)

a quick help for loting
green creeps items level 1 permanet and charged
orange creeps level 2 and 3 permanet and charged
red creeps level 4, 5 and 6 permanet and charged

if you go to advanced, objet table you can create tables and you know, you dont have to do the work manually creep by creep

but again, very nice map

Hmmmmmm.... Thank you! I hated editing every creeps dropings! Ill edit it soon

 

[Binsu]

Played your map and I must say this is a good map though ways are quite limited. But here is my review:

[+] Good Points:
-Terrain looks good to me. Just learn that melee doesnt need to be so decorated so for me the terrain is not empty and also doodads, destructbles and such doesnt seem distracting. Terrain is not flat. Good job!
-Map has required resources:

• Gold Mines
• Goblin Merchant
• Goblin Labaratory
• More...

-Player positioning looks fine and nothing badly positioned or such hapenings.
-Creeps are balanced enough.

[-] Bad Points:
-Ways are quite narrow or limited to me. You can make the ways bigger.

[] Suggestions:
-Even with good terrain, everything is not perfect we all know so keep on improving it.
-Make ways bigger.

Overall, good melee map with good terrain. has required resources, balanced creeps, and such..... Rated 4/5 and +4 REP!

Voting also for Approval!

 

[Orcnet]

map approved, but uh needs a little arrangement from those main base creep camps:

 

[Arrr]

quick reply

remove some unpathable/unbuildable doodads (those which don't allow players to build an expansion) from the nears of the mines, and remove unbuildable terrain near expansions
And "fill" the middle fountain with pathing plochers, placing them arount will still permit units to walk into it (for example blink, or with zeppelin)
There are too many spaces between trees