The Queen's Garden

[Moderator]

Vengeancekael
Date: 2012/Oct/12 18:56:11
[Please do not send me a message, use Staff Contact]

Comment: [Approved]
What's up with all the item drops in the center?
And yellow camps at the gold mines expansions would be better, you could instead put one big red camp in the center.

Staff Contact - Rules

 

[sonofjay]

Been a while since I saw a 8 player melee map. Gonna check this one for sure when I get some time.

 

[Remixer]

I would be greatfull if you would do a review

 

[sonofjay]

Okay I have some spare time atm(done reviewing for finals), I'll check this out and leave a review,

EDIT:

The map layout is symmetric but it lacks strategic points the only strategic point that I can see is the center of the map and the waygates. Probably the biggest hole in your melee map is that top, left, right and bottom players are on a great disadvantage against the corner players since their bases are way to open compared to corner player. Terrain wise, it is way to empty, the cliffs outside the playable area is way to random, at least put some effort to make it pleasant to the eyes, same with the tile variation, some spots is decent some are just way to plain, the emptiness is a big plus making the map way to empty, I suggest to put some doodads to fill the empty spots etc. Drops are fine and players have enough resources. Overall I'll rate it 2/5, I hope that you'll update your map soon. And as you do, please contact me so I can re-review it.

Anyway nice attempt for a 8 player map, +rep

 

[Arrr]

I agree with sonofjay, exept for the items:

-Max 1 item drop for green camp
-Max 2 item drops for red-orange camps

ItemLv-CampLv:
ActivatedLv 1 : Lv 4-12
ActivatedLv 2 : Lv 11->
Rune : On Shops
PermanentLv 1 : Lv 5-11
PermanentLv 2 : Lv 11-15
PermanentLv 3 : Lv 15-18
PermanentLv 4 : Lv 17-23
PermanentLv 5 : Lv 20->
ChargedLv 2 : Lv7-17
ChargedLv 3 : Lv14-17
ChargedLv 4 : Lv16-20
ChargedLv 5 : Lv19-23
ChargedLv 6 :24->
Manifactures : Lv24->

This is an indicative table, wich can change from case to case (for example Lv of each creep of the Camp), I use it to have an idea of item drops

 

[Dess_26]

I played it and I like it. I find very interesting the idea of having a destructible fountain in the middle of the map, even though in the beginning I said this is not a a thing that you can meet in a normal melee map. But is something new for me and I really like it. You can destroy it in strategic moments of the game. +1 Rep for this

 

[Remixer]

Maps Updated!
All my melee maps has been updated to the Last Melee Version same time. You can check them all out.

Also uploading some old maps soon, updated of course.
- Remixer

 

[Remixer]

I think I'm gonna re-create this one, I do not like it now ,(

 

[deepstrasz]

-it kind of looks ugly to have units placed exactly on the Way Gates
-I don't know what to think about that fountain that can be destroyed
-the hills/cliffs could use some doodads as they look quite plain

I give it a 3.5/5.

 

[Remixer]

-it kind of looks ugly to have units placed exactly on the Way Gates
-I don't know what to think about that fountain that can be destroyed
-the hills/cliffs could use some doodads as they look quite plain

I give it a 3.5/5.

Yup... some of the reasons this is the second map going to get a rework, the first being Forged Thunder