Taguski Cave

[Moderator]

09:46, 10th Jun 2008
Rui: Pending. Needs more work.

Septimus

Good Point

[+]

Neutral Point

[!]

Bad Point

[-] Tavern should not be guarded
[-] Amount of tree and gold is very less
[-] Monster doesn't drop item
[-] Gold mine must had monster guarded it even if the player starting location is at there cause if there is no player playing for that area. It would be left defenseless which could be used as a advantage.
[-] Upper part player had slightly advantage to reach middle much faster.
[-] Tavern could only be reach from west side, but even though it could be reach from west side. The small ramp making it impossible to be reach.

Overall - 1/5
Rejected

 

[Rui]

Yay, more melee maps for me to test. Going to test them tomorrow or something =)

EDIT:
Ok, still pending. Not with a good qualification. This seriously needs more work.
[-]The idea on the center was good, however, it is too placed up north, thus more easily accessible to players with Teal's and Purple's starting locations;
[-]Poor ground texture variation;
[-]Some starting locations are wrong placed, the main is too far from the Gold Mine;
[-]I see the idea with the starting locations, however, this can create imbalance;
[-]Creeps are not well chosen, their placement is weird and they don't drop anything;
[-]The Tavern is unaccessible and it is guarded. HEAVILY GUARDED. Taverns must not be guarded and players should have easy access to them.

My rating right now is 1/5 (Unacceptable), sorry if it sounds harsh, but this REALLY needs more work.

 

[Incarnation]

This is one of my first melee maps and, as you said with the two others I posted, they still need work. I had a feeling this one would gibe problems.