Small Sanctuary

[Moderator]

17:52, 20th Jun 2008
Septimus:

hellblazer Review

Hey Matyko

Ok, right to the review... sorry If I'm a bit harsh.

PROS---

-Interesting and Original Terrain
-With a little more work it could make a really good map.

CONS---

-The Terrain is lacking, and a bit odd at some parts
-The Units are placed a bit badly
-The Unit in the middle, it's a bit stupid, because you can't get there
-Some Goblin Lab's would be useful, so players can fly across the abyss to the enemy player
-Another Gold mine? 1 Gold Mine per person really is not enough for a good game


Nice map Matyko, and as I said, little more work and it'll be really good.

Septimus Comment :

Good Point

[+]

Bad Point

[-] Just like hellblazer said, it is bad to place a unit at the place that cannot be reach by ground unit.
[-] Need at least 2 gold mine per player
[-] There is no goblin lab to enable player to fly to the middle.

Overall - 2/5
Reject

This map would be ok after you had fix those error, before you fix it. I would set it to rejection, it had 2 vote for rejection anyway.

 

[hellblazer-14]

Lacking A little

Hey Matyko

Ok, right to the review... sorry If I'm a bit harsh.

PROS---

-Interesting and Original Terrain
-With a little more work it could make a really good map.

CONS---

-The Terrain is lacking, and a bit odd at some parts
-The Units are placed a bit badly
-The Unit in the middle, it's a bit stupid, because you can't get there
-Some Goblin Lab's would be useful, so players can fly across the abyss to the enemy player
-Another Gold mine? 1 Gold Mine per person really is not enough for a good game


Nice map Matyko, and as I said, little more work and it'll be really good.