Poisoned Gold

[Moderator]

16:28, 11th Jan 2011
-Kobas-:
Map Status: Rejected (until updated)
Broken Rules:
/
Comment

 

[Pourquoi]

Fix author's name. Improve the description.

 

[Figueiredo00]

the terrain looks bad, some places are really empty, other places are hard to mobilize the troops.

and im thinking, its better let one fool lost his entire army trying to take one of this goldmines in the center, and steal it from him, than try to take it by yourself dont you think?

 

[drakexx]

i like it 4/5 +apro

 

[matej]

nice to see someone still making a melee maps. its nice, but only thing you should change is goldmines. i think better will be if there is only two goldimes on middle.

 

[limuka]

the terrain looks bad, some places are really empty, other places are hard to mobilize the troops.

yeah i know but i got to say i created the whole map today and didnt really worked on perfection and like i said my terraining skills arent good.

edit: ill try to remove some water to get more place for troops to pass and il add some more doodads

 

[limuka]

its better let one fool lost his entire army trying to take one of this goldmines in the center, and steal it from him, than try to take it by yourself dont you think?

yeah true but its cuz i had to improve discription so i wrote it down quickly il change it a bit.

 

[WaremDarkslayer]

I think that, poor description aside, you have understood the meaning of having symmetry in melee maps.You will improve if you practice.

Now in your description you must have:
details of your map -you have that
screenshots of your map- you don't have those
gameplay/hints- melee maps only need hints , which you haven't put
description of the place/location - basically the scenario editor description
For now my Rating:N/A

 

[limuka]

I think that, poor description aside, you have understood the meaning of having symmetry in melee maps.You will improve if you practice.

Now in your description you must have:
details of your map -you have that
screenshots of your map- you don't have those
gameplay/hints- melee maps only need hints , which you haven't put
description of the place/location - basically the scenario editor description
For now my Rating:N/A

il get a screenie, but i dont get what u mean with "hints" if some1 could explain me that il be able to improve (sry if this question may sound noobish but this is my first melee map and on my other maps (all disaproved) no1 said anything about that)

 

[Figueiredo00]

I think that, poor description aside, you have understood the meaning of having symmetry in melee maps.You will improve if you practice.

Now in your description you must have:
details of your map -you have that
screenshots of your map- you don't have those
gameplay/hints- melee maps only need hints , which you haven't put
description of the place/location - basically the scenario editor description
For now my Rating:N/A

screenshots for a melee map? is this really necessary?

 

[limuka]

screenshots for a melee map? is this really necessary?

ill just leave it like this

 

[-Kobas-]

Moderation

Poisoned Gold
Created by Limuka ; Uploaded by: limuka

Review

Can you upload some screenshots to your map description, you will present your map better that way.

Other that that we have problem here, map is empty, you miss doodads buddy! Large number of them, some tiles as well, and because this is melee map I can't approve it in this condition!

Please add improve map, fix that 50.000 gold per gold mine (don't go over 20.000 please) and item drops!
Add some more eutral hostile units (try with neutral camps this time)

For now Rejected (until updated) (Please don't wait to much after month or more it will be rejected)
Have a nice day!

Broken Rules:
/
Thread Cleaned:
/
Status: Rejected (until updated)