Please Erase this map

[Moderator]

19:38, 10th Aug 2010
ap0calypse: Rejected

 

[Warhunter]

It's not an normal melee if you've added races to the map.
It's moore of an alternate melee.

 

[Lightmyght]

good, a new friend who help me . You are right but im always confused the real map type. Melee or strategy? Answer : Strategy with alternate melee map.

 

[Feorix]

i've played the goblins:
i like the race
you could make custom heroes,not the heroes of the tavern
the idea for the spell to make buildings is not bad
3,5/5

 

[Ironside]

THW Description: Contains some information, although nothing that can be called a good description yet. (1.5/4)
Map Description: Some additional information, but not good... (1/3)
Loading Screen: You don't use a loading screen, but i gues you better add it, because this is just - points... (0/3

All together for these 3: 2.5/10

Actually looks good to me, but it's too plain and so, even tho it's something like a desert i guess ... (6/10)

First of all i must say; I played Demons then Necromancer, the necromancer? the blight created by the buildings is far to small, i could hardly expand my base. Then where are any soldiers and workers for the necromancer?? You must add a quest menu with a guide for necromancer because I didn't get him at all... Just this alone made me quit the game and just write this review fast... No AI either... Which in my opinion is very very important in Altered melee maps... (5/10)

Quest menu: None (0/5)
Hints: None (0/5)

All together for these 2: 0/10

0%-49% = 1/5 vote for rejection
50%-60% = 2/5 but i vote for either rejection or approval
61%-70% = 2/5 but i vote for approval
71%-80% = 3/5 vote for approval
81%-92% = 4/5 vote for approval
93%-100% = 5/5 vote for approval

Map Rating: 1 (Unacceptable)

Total: 13.5/40
= 33.75%


Vote for Approval?= No
Vote for Rejection?= Yes

5 (Highly Recommended)
4 (Recommended)
3 (Useful)
2 (Lacking)
1 (Unacceptable)

 

[Lightmyght]

i have upgrade the map : i make the quest for help the player, Necromancer build a Corps Tower for upgrade to Dark Tower for enlarge the blight. Not a alternate map, because the AI for the new factions are not make : I know nothing about scripts and triggers (i sorry).

Thank Barathrum for your help and approve my map please.

 

[Dark Soul]

Trust me, start some basic triggering, it will get easier as you go along. Simple map, i'll give it a 3/5 for hardwork!

 

[Lightmyght]

thank to you Dark Soul (a name from Shining Force^^). Your note is good, because the AI is missing and this game are not totally perfect with lesser exp i have.

 

[Dark Soul]

Shining force? lol, no maps are perfect, thus different versions excist. Go see some trigger guides in hiveworkshop, it help. I started by playing around with simple triggers, fun to see how they work out. Cheers!

 

[Lightmyght]

so, you are right all : Its a Altered Melee. I understand now XD (after 3 mouth :S, i sleeping in the moon lol!!)

 

[Hunter9G]

I wouldnt rate the map on a special basis because im new. but until i test it all i can say for now is its 5.5 mb and so unplayable on bnet which is a prob without any ais either. ill message back after i try it out.

 

[Lightmyght]

Unplayable on bnet! Thank for this precision Hunter9G. I understand why i 2\5 and not 3.5\5.


Edit: strange, the maximum weight is 8 mb for some last path, so i was right for this 5,5mb. Because before this path the maximum weight is 4 mb. So i need more explication please.

 

[Delpiroth]

Review

+Good Things+

[+] Custom models
[+] OK Terrain at best.

-Bad Things-

[-] Small amount of wood on the map.
[-] Most icons don't suit the buildings.
[-] No food producer for Demons !?
[-] Bad spelling.
[-] Spells are just the ordinary with changed names and descriptions.
[-] Why make the altar the starting building for the Necromancer?
[-] The new races are boring.
[-] Bad map overall!

Overall:

This map needs so much more work! 1/5 Vote for Rejection.

 

[Lightmyght]

Ah yes, I do not know why the photo of "Dynasty Warrior" conceal my card on this site. Yet, I never set. Surely a person who does not love me. : (But I did nothing wrong.) Please help me remove it.

 

[Cweener]

Mass Purging Template Version 4.0
Rejection

Reason for not approving:
The terraining here, while original, is bad.
Needs more tiles and merging.
Need to fix the ramps with black voids.
Need to fix your triggers for sure, good lord, they leak a lot.
They are also inefficient.