Night Run

[Moderator]

22:12, 23rd Jun 2009
Rui: This map does not use the most recent Warcraft patch, and thus, does not contain the latest balance fixes. Rejected^{(until updated)}.

 

[APproject]

Cute terrain though.

 

[yakonshus]

Cute terrain though.

Thats what i call a lovely comment.

 

[Septimus]

This is my review about this map.

1) Terrain at bottom and middle of the map look good, but I have to said No to the upper terrain. The terrain at top of the map seems to be lacking. Try improve it.
2) Every gold mine must be guarded with creep even though there is a player starting location on it; playing this map at FFA 3 player would resulted into 1 player have a major advantage over the other. The gold mine with player starting location doesn't need to be guard by creep only if the map was a 1 vs 1 map.
3) Item distribution - Some creep was rather high level and yet it drop a low level item (Example would be the Giant Wolf), try fix that.

This map status was between 2/5 (Lacking) and 3/5 (Useful), once you fix this 3 error. It would be good enough for approval.

2/5 as for now.

 

[yakonshus]

1) Terrain at bottom and middle of the map look good, but I have to said No to the upper terrain. The terrain at top of the map seems to be lacking. Try improve it.

The terrain at the top is just as good as the lower part, the differance lay in the rain, but if i added rain to northen part, it would look just as lumpy, and i dont want that.

Beside, i dont think your terrain in your map: Heion Forest look as good as this does, but that is my oppinion.

2) Every gold mine must be guarded with creep even though there is a player starting location on it; playing this map at FFA 3 player would resulted into 1 player have a major advantage over the other. The gold mine with player starting location doesn't need to be guard by creep only if the map was a 1 vs 1 map.

3) Item distribution - Some creep was rather high level and yet it drop a low level item (Example would be the Giant Wolf), try fix that.

Fixed!

Hope this will improve it to 3/5 in your eyes.

 

[Septimus]

Beside, i dont think your terrain in your map: Heion Forest look as good as this does, but that is my oppinion.

I just only have 1 advice to you, do not overestimate yourself. For your information, the staff at this site are strict at the quality term. If you do not get at least a rating 4 from me, your map would struggle to gain approval from the staff as I am very lenient at quality control.

And no, unless you fix the 3 problem that I mention. I would stick to 2/5.

If you want to know what is lacking over the terrain at north, feel free to request Rui to review it. He could explain it much better than me.

 

[yakonshus]

I said that that was my oppinion, not that it actually was that.

And i have fixed the things you mentioned.