Magic Palace

[Moderator]

Vengeancekael: Private Message
Date: 2011/Dec/15 18:36:28

Reasons:

Other:
Check out the tutorials section: Tutorials
Check out the Map Development Section: Map Development Section
Check out the World Editor Help Zone (Trigger issues, object editor, overall WE issues): WE Help Zone
Comment: *Symmetric
*Enough Wood
*Bonus Goldmines
*Multiple Shops
*Green Creeps close to starting points
*Different item tables
*Also red creep camp at the center of the map along with fountain of mana
*Neat way of implementing the shipyards
*Main problem: The aesthetics, check the screenshots below, they should be self-explanatory, the benches are not rotated properly, a lot of the areas are just too empty, you should add more flowers and statues as well, also some of the doodads don't even fit, ...

Rating: 3/5 - Approved
Admin Contact - Resource Moderation - Rules

 

[Blood Raven]

the terrain is a bit monotone and i dont see much environment at all. Improve this. otherwise, not bad, but... the terrain is one of the main points of the melee maps, fix it.

 

[Vengeancekael]

*Symmetric
*Enough Wood
*Bonus Goldmines
*Multiple Shops
*Green Creeps close to starting points
*Different item tables
*Also red creep camp at the center of the map along with fountain of mana
*Neat way of implementing the shipyards
*Main problem: The aesthetics, check the screenshots below, they should be self-explanatory, the benches are not rotated properly, a lot of the areas are just too empty, you should add more flowers and statues as well, also some of the doodads don't even fit, ...

Rating: 3/5 - Approved

 

[hellsinger]

First off, I want to say it makes me really happy to see people still enjoy making melee maps for WC3 and some of my favorites are fan made and that with the rpg's makes me return to wc3 over and over again.

I see an incredible potencial in this map, but if I have to say something that I dislinke not just of this but in general is that the excesive simetrics makes the natural parts looks unnatural.

So, the buildings part is excelent but the natural part of the terrain is monotone. Please fix that making it more "random" with enviromental things and random paths.