Got Three Ideas for a new map, only want to make one-Advice?

[MShadows]

Ok I just finished my new map Realm of Shadows RPG. You can check it out in the map section.
Anyway here are 3 ideas I have for my next map.

Idea #1
Ok this map is an RPG where 8 heroes journey to the depths of Hell. These heroes can either be holy heroes(like crusaders, paladins, clerics, priests), or maybe just regualar heroes (humans only). They can either be sent their as a punishment (for major sins they may have commited) and if they survive, they will be pardoned; or as a quest to rid the universe of Lucifer for all eternity.
Anyway, this will be a story type RPG with cinematics and such.
Several Villains in this RPG to use as bosses:
1.
Lucifer (fallen angel of heaven) - Final Boss who greets the heroes warmly with a lake of fire surrounding him.
2.
Cain (killed his brother out of vengence in Genesis Ch. 4. and became a walking punishment.) Anyone who hurts Cain will be Avengend Sevenfold. That means any damage done to him will come back seven times to the attacker(including spells).
3.
Nero (Terrible Emperor who ordered the crucifiction of Jesus Christ. He also burned his own city and ordered the death of his mother)
Nero will command a small army of demons who will gladly try and take and torcher the heroes souls.
4.
Legion (Demon/s who possessed a man in the book of Matthew.) Legion is called Legion because they are many in one. Meaning this demon will divide and divide until there is nothing left to kill. "We are Legion for we are many" will be his opening line.
5.
Belial (haven't done much research on this guy, but hes like the right hand demon of Lucifer)
He's probably going to a big and fat like a Pit Lord. Once i do some research on him, then his description will be more prominent.
6.
Samael (Supposably the snake who tricked Adam and Eve in Genesis, he's also supposed to be the 7 heeded serpant beast in Revelations) This dudes going to be a snake monster, then morph into a 7 headed beast when hes about to die. He's also going to have all these snake minions guard him.
7.
Judas (the demon who resided in Judas when he betrayed Jesus for silver) This guy is going to be like a rogue type demon who is very sneaky and stealthful.
8.
Harlot (dont know the actual name of this chick, but shes supposed to be the harlot who is beside the 7 headed beast in Revelations) Just a Demonic female. Probably be guarded by succubuses and will be near Samael.
9-16.
The seven Deadly sins
(Greed, Gluttony, Lust, Pride, Envy, Vengance, Sloth)

Other Cool stuff,
-At exactly 3:00 AM., 7 demons will surround and attack a random hero, every day until the game is complete.
-Different terrain for the different parts of Hell
-8 heroes who can be switched at any time and can keep all their stats. So basically they are shared by each player.
-Ingame cinematics to introduce each boss
-custom skins, icons, abilities and models
Its BNET friendly(as long as you dont get many ignorant ppl who just leave as soon as they die once, which is very rare to find good ppl to play with) and Single Player Friendly(controlling 4 heroes at a time).

WOW, that was a long one... anyway heres the next idea I got...

Idea #2
An Arena style map where you catch monsters and fight other players.
POKEMON!? ARE YOU SERIOUS???
No its NOT pokemon.
Its regular monsters like Vampires, ghosts, witches, goblins, zombies, werewolves, etc...
You capture them, level them up, and store them in your BASE. In your BASE, you can move your stored monsters to positions to ready yourself for 1v1 monster, 2v2 monsters, 3v3 monsters, or 4v4 monster battles between 2 players. There will maybe 6-8 players total, no teams. Every 10 or so minutes, there will be a duel, and you have to ready yourself with the strongest lineup. Winning qualifications aren't known yet. Its BNET friendly but not very Single Player Friendly.

Idea #3
A final fantasy tactics type map. I'm not talking about like choosing jobs and such, I mean like moving in squares and attacking once per turn per unit. Choose your race, and hire mercenaries to fight in a Tactics style map. I was origianlly going to do this a long time ago, but i can't figure out how to make the game engine. (I dont even know how to begin) I have the model for a square tile, but it seems waaay too complex, so if anyone had any insight on how to do this, help would be appreciated.
Battle.net friendly if it isn't too complex, Single player friendly if the AI isnt hard to make.

Ok, there you go. 3 cool ideas, only one will be worked on. suggestions please!!!!!!!

 

[Los_Tacos]

#1 sounds interesting.

 

[VGsatomi]

#3 would be in incredible hit if you got it to work right. It is far from impossible, but my GAWD it would take more triggering then one could ever hope to do. Hope you like staring at the trigger screen for days on end , but it would be a guarenteed success.
-VGsatomi

 

[Sansui]

choice 3 fo the winz

I could probably send you my map that already has the movement and combat system finished for that type of game.... BUT that would take away the fun of making the map.

the other 2 suck, just thought i should say that.

 

[Mecheon]

1 is just... Meh
2 could be interesting if you had a nice choice of monsters to battle with. I'm not talking crummy things like vampires and werewolves, but things that requires stratagy to pull off. Attackers, buffers, ranged fighters, whatever

Now, if you could pull off 3...

Then you would have probably created THE system that the mighty game known as Shining Force used. Using squares to move based on level and stuff

Shining Force rules

 

[qwerty]

i always wanted to make a map like idea 2. the concept is cool, but you need to make everything else, too.

 

[MShadows]

Hey, sansui dude, I wouldn't mind it at all if you sent me that map, cause i need INSPIRATION. Its almost looking like a dead idea now... cause its um really hard... I think I might go with #1, because i think it might be cool, but if you dont trust me, then thats cool too.